Assessing Trump's Strategy for Cheaper Housing: Can It Succeed?
President Trump recently introduced two key initiatives to make buying a home more affordable in light of rising housing prices and increased mortgage rates.
His plan includes prohibiting major corporate investors from acquiring homes and directing federal efforts to reduce mortgage rates.
According to Trump, these measures are part of a broader effort to restore housing affordability, as announced in a social media post on January 8.
The cost of homeownership has significantly increased over the years, attributed to a lack of affordable housing and, since 2022, rising interest rates on loans. Experts caution, however, that many contributing factors to these issues are outside federal influence, casting doubt on the potential effectiveness of Trump's proposals.
Challenges with the Housing Supply
Trump's initiatives target two major difficulties: high mortgage interest and competition from large investors, but these strategies may not sufficiently tackle the core problem of insufficient housing availability.
The shortage is largely a result of years of under-construction since the 2008 financial downturn and a reluctance by current homeowners to sell their properties due to favorable loan rates secured during the prior recession.
As highlighted by Gennadiy Goldberg from TD Securities, resolving the housing supply deficit in the U.S. will demand a significant increase in construction activities.
Goldman Sachs estimates indicate that constructing around four million additional homes would be necessary to address the shortfall adequately.
Janneke Ratcliffe from the Urban Institute reiterates that creating new housing solutions is a time-consuming process.
High land prices hinder the ability to expand housing stock effectively, and changes to local zoning laws could help, yet such measures occur locally, beyond federal jurisdiction.
Limitations of Reduced Mortgage Rates
While Trump's policies are anticipated to enhance demand for homes, they may inadvertently result in higher housing prices, suggests Goldberg. Lower interest rates can attract more buyers, leading to increased home values and intensifying the issue of limited supply.
Simply making loans cheaper doesn't resolve the long-term problem; easier access to mortgages might only accelerate price growth, says the analyst.
Meanwhile, the proposed ban on large investment firms like Invitation Homes and Blackstone purchasing single-family homes might minimally impact due to their small market share.
Goldberg notes that larger corporate investors make up a minor fraction of the total possible housing stock, roughly 1%, per the American Enterprise Institute.
The plan lacks clarity on whether these investors would need to divest current holdings, a factor crucial in expanding housing availability.
While Trump's adjustments might bring slight relief, according to Carl Weinberg of High Frequency Economics, reducing institutional purchases could modestly lower prices.
Ben Ayres of Nationwide Economics anticipates that a $200 billion federal purchase in mortgage-backed securities might ease loan rates by up to 0.35 percentage points, sparking more economic activity.
Ultimately, the consensus among economists is that significantly addressing housing affordability requires dealing with the underlying scarcity. Unless new supply solutions are enacted, affordability issues are likely to remain, as emphasized by Edward Pinto from AEI Housing Center.
Pinto stresses the need to either better use the existing housing supply or facilitate the construction of new homes promptly to solve the shortage problem effectively.



Leave a Reply