The Sole Counting That Counts
For those looking at happiness, well-being, or economic expansion, GDP should not be ignored.
Introduction
In 1972, the ruler of Bhutan declared that 'Gross National Happiness is more crucial than Gross Domestic Product.' This proclamation charmed the global population. Finally, someone acknowledged what many believed: happiness holds more significance than wealth.
At that time, Bhutan was struggling economically. Half a century later, it still finds itself at the lower end of global rankings in GDP per capita. Bhutan's Gross Domestic Product per person, a measure of economic output per person, remains weak.
Today, people in Bhutan live longer, averaging 73 years compared to 51 in 1972, matching the global mean. Nevertheless, leaders are worried about high emigration rates driven mainly by the search for better economic prospects. Bhutan’s domestic surveys indicate improvements in happiness since 2010. Yet, international assessments report a decrease in Bhutanese self-reported happiness.
Contrasting Bhutan’s path, South Korea began a different journey in 1961 when General Park Chung-hee came to power with a goal to transform the economy. The country’s GDP per capita was around $93, even less than Bhutan’s back then. The plan was focused on industrial development, minimizing dependency on US assistance, and becoming competitive in global markets, tracked through five-year economic plans targeting growth.
Specific data on South Koreans’ happiness during that period might be lacking, yet quality of life seemingly soared. Life expectancy rose from 54 in 1960 to 66 in 1980, now reaching approximately 83, surpassing Bhutan’s figures. Infant mortality dramatically decreased by nearly 97%. Transitioning from war devastation and foreign aid reliance, South Korea evolved into the 14th largest global economy, with GDP per capita surpassing $30,000. Economic plans measured success through GDP numbers, clearly reflecting transformative growth.
GDP's Fundamental Role
This contrasts against Bhutan, underscoring GDP’s significance. Bhutan prioritized happiness over economic progress, but this led to marginal increases in happiness without significant enhancements in living standards. Meanwhile, South Korea pursued tangible development targets, measured success with GDP, and achieved economic transformation without focusing explicitly on happiness indicators. Surveys consistently show South Korea ranking higher than Bhutan in self-reported happiness.
With GDP facing robust criticism from economic commentators, including public figures like Elon Musk, some propose alternative measures like happiness and well-being indices or sustainability metrics. While these alternatives highlight important aspects missing from GDP, they often overlook its critical role in reflecting genuine economic development. A growing economy lays the groundwork for pursuing and achieving additional objectives.
Understanding GDP
Acknowledging GDP’s irreplaceable role requires understanding its definition and purpose. Essentially, GDP is a 'national account,' functioning as a comprehensive record of a country's economic activities—similar to a company's financial ledger tracking revenues and expenditures.
During the early 1930s, amid the Great Depression, economist Simon Kuznets developed the first national account for the U.S. Congress to assess the speed and extent of economic recovery.
Before, policymakers had access to price indices and production figures but lacked a consolidated view of the economy. Kuznets tackled various conceptual and practical hurdles, such as aggregating diverse transactions across industries, preventing the double count of inter-business sales, and compiling data from businesses unused to such reporting.
While GDP history is intriguing, what matters more today is understanding its indication. GDP quantifies the aggregate market value of all final goods and services produced within a country within a specific timeframe. Each term in this definition carries importance.
Criticisms and Omissions of GDP
GDP does omit certain elements. Designed to gauge market production, it excludes unpaid labor. Home-cooked meals for family, for example, don’t feature in GDP, although paying for a meal does. Rebuilding efforts post-hurricanes add to GDP, despite wealth losses due to destruction. Additionally, GDP doesn't consider environmental impacts, as most costs like carbon emissions often lack explicit prices.
It also fails to capture income distribution variances or distinguish between welfare-improving activities and problem-solving responses, like securing homes during crime spates. However, these omissions are neither concealed nor contentious.
Disparaging GDP from its measurement standpoint, Nobel laureate Joseph Stiglitz emphasized that flawed metrics could distort decisions and pointed out certain exclusions from GDP. Similar critiques, like Stiglitz’s concern about narrow focuses leading to policy oversights in health, education, equality, and the environment, must be directed at policymakers rather than GDP itself. Historical creators acknowledged the scope GDP was meant to serve.
Other dissenters like journalist David Pilling caution against GDP-centric policies for potentially exacerbating social and environmental disparities. Still, such critiques are more philosophical, recognizing the inadequacy of GDP as a sole developmental barometer and advocating for more encompassing alternatives.
Why GDP Persists and Its Broader Implications
Despite these views, GDP stands as an influential metric by closely correlating with essential living indicators. For instance, nations with increased GDP per capita typically report higher life expectancies. Although critics often use specific examples like New Zealand’s life expectancy contrasting the U.S., it generally casts patterns of longer lives, reduced infant mortality, and improved education linked with economic wealth.
Furthermore, country wealth often corresponds with reported happiness, reinforcing GDP as a commonly linked factor in happiness reports, prompting its inclusion amongst comprehensive indices.
GDP's Practical Utility
The global embrace of GDP as an authoritative measure, producing periodic quarterly estimates, stems from its unique utility. As a near real-time economic gauge, GDP reports enable policymakers to identify recessions timely and fashion appropriate responses—a lesson from the Great Depression—aided by advanced data technologies for accuracy and precision.
This pragmatic advantage is crucial: GDP facilitates understanding of economic capacity on both national and comparative scales, offering perspective across time to inform development policies.
However, potential conflicts exist where GDP growth might misalign with other societal goals. While elite athletic training metaphors might illustrate narrow trade-offs, broad national policy requires insights about expanding productive capacity, and GDP thus encapsulates success in achieving such capacity.



Leave a Reply