Discover a European-Inspired Hidden Street in NYC

Tucked away in New York City's Upper West Side is a neighborhood that feels more like a charming European lane than a bustling city street.

Pomander Walk, a gated enclave nestled between 94th and 95th Streets just a short stroll from Central Park, remains a well-kept secret to many locals.

This quaint street now offers an unusual chance to own a slice of its scenic charm, as two condos have surfaced on the market for the combined price of $1.39 million. These one-bedroom apartments, located on the second and third floors, have the potential to be combined into a duplex.

"It truly is a precious discovery," said listing agent Kim Shankman to Business Insider. "Being here, you can hardly believe you're in the heart of New York City."

History and Design of Pomander Walk

This mini-neighborhood emerged in 1921 thanks to the vision of Thomas Healy, an Irish developer. The area took its name from "Pomander Walk," a 1910 English play, and became officially recognized as a city landmark in 1982.

Originally intended to be a single grand edifice, financial constraints led Healy to construct individual Tudor-style houses instead. Shankman reveals that the 61-unit community rarely sees properties go on sale, as owners typically hold onto them for extensive periods. Her clients, for instance, cherished these condos for over thirty years before deciding to move on.

"The family finds letting go challenging," noted Shankman. "Their hope is for someone to fall in love with it just as deeply as they did."

Charming Tudor-Style Architecture

Thomas Healy, arriving in New York at the age of 15, envisioned these buildings, which are characterized by their distinctive Tudor style. Initially planned as one expansive building, the restriction of funds resulted in 27 separate three-story condos.

A Landmark Oasis

The tranquil Pomander Walk, bordered by wrought-iron gates, evokes the ambiance of its theatrical namesake, set near London's River Thames. It's this unique background that makes Pomander Walk an idyllic escape in Manhattan, just a few blocks from Central Park.

Award-Winning Rehabilitation

A significant exterior renovation in 2009 earned Pomander Walk a "Building Rehabilitation" accolade from Landmark West, highlighting the careful preservation of its architectural charm.

Unique Living Opportunity

These available units, which can be combined into a larger home, are located in a building composed of three stories. Each 500-square-foot apartment features one bedroom, a bathroom, a living area, and a kitchen with dining space.

Rare Availability

Since 2009, only a handful of units in this hidden urban sanctuary have been listed for rent, according to StreetEasy. Only recently, a two-bedroom condo was sold quietly, finalizing at $900,000 in 2023.

An Idyllic Neighborhood in Manhattan

"It's extraordinarily unique and idyllic," Shankman noted, describing the exceptional appeal of Pomander Walk.