Increased Use of Solitary Confinement for Immigrants Under Trump Administration
A recent analysis by Physicians for Human Rights, utilizing federal records accessed through Freedom of Information Act requests, highlights a significant rise in solitary confinement within immigration detention facilities under the Trump administration.
Escalating Numbers and Influences
From April 2024 to May 2025, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) isolated at least 10,588 detainees in solitary conditions. This study was enriched with contributions from experts at Harvard University’s Peeler Immigration Lab and Harvard Law School.
Research indicates that the solitary confinement rate during the first four months of the current administration surged, doubling the average growth seen from 2018 to 2023 and exceeding the late 2024 statistics by over six times.
Concerns From Health Experts
Dr. Katherine Peeler, associated with Physicians for Human Rights and Harvard Medical School, expressed alarm over the increase, noting a 6.5% rise in the monthly numbers of individuals placed in solitary confinement from February to May.
The practice is often used as either a punitive measure or for the alleged protection of at-risk individuals, with no formal response from ICE or the Department of Homeland Security to inquiries about this practice.
Impacts on Vulnerable Populations
Solitary confinement is deemed a form of torture by the UN if imposed for more than 15 consecutive days. ICE designates detainees as vulnerable if they have significant health issues, disabilities, are elderly, pregnant, identify with certain sexual orientations or gender identities, or have suffered from abuse.
According to the report, in early 2025, vulnerable detainees were in isolation for an average of 38 days, as opposed to 14 days at the end of 2021.
A Widening Scope and Federal Recommendations
The use of solitary confinement in immigration settings has escalated over the past decade, a trajectory potentially worsened by the billions allocated by Congress for expanded detention capabilities this year. The report suggests a governmental halt to solitary confinement for immigrants in civil deportation, alongside recommendations for state and Congressional oversight.
Detention Center Insights and Broader Patterns
As of September 7, around 59,000 immigrants were in ICE detention facilities, reflecting an aggressive recruitment effort to augment deportation officers. In examining specific cases in New England, Physicians for Human Rights identified extensive misuse of solitary confinement for arbitrary or retaliatory objectives.
In California, there were 2,546 recorded instances of people being confined in solitude from 2018 to 2023, with a notable number reported for 2024-2025.
Recent changes in data reporting from ICE, now focusing on unique individuals rather than multiple placements of the same person, have provided clarity—particularly noting that 596 were isolated within that timeframe.
Facilities With High Solitary Confinement Rates
California had two significant facilities—Adelanto ICE Processing Center and Otay Mesa Detention Center—ranking in the top five for solitary confinement instances in the period under review.
In 2024-2025, solitary confinement was notably prevalent at facilities in states like Pennsylvania, Texas, New York, Arizona, and Louisiana, aligning with ICE's focus on Republican-stronghold locales.
Further examination uncovered the repeated application of solitary for over 14,000 occasions from 2018 to 2023, with outliers like the Otay Mesa detainee facing nearly two years in isolation.



Leave a Reply