L.A. County Limits ICE Access to Travel Data
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors has decided to implement stricter controls regarding federal immigration authorities accessing data gleaned from locals by the Sheriff’s Department's automated license plate readers.
This decision follows the introduction of a measure by Supervisor Hilda Solis, aimed at enhancing oversight of the information collected by these devices, which are used extensively by law enforcement.
California law already prohibits local law enforcement from sharing data from license plate readers with federal bodies, like ICE, unless a warrant is presented.
In the wake of heightened deportations during the summer, the Board of Supervisors decided to enforce more stringent transparency around who requests this sensitive data from the Sheriff's Department and under what circumstances it is disseminated.
The new policy will clarify that such data cannot be 'revealed, handed over, or otherwise made accessible’ to immigration authorities, except under direct legal requirement or with a court order.
According to the motion, residents of Los Angeles County, who rely heavily on cars for daily mobility, should not fear their travel patterns are being secretly monitored, stored, and distributed in a manner violating their privacy.
Supervisor Kathryn Barger opposed the motion, primarily because it directs the county to advocate for a bill that restricts the retention duration of most license plate data to 60 days — a proposal met with resistance from law enforcement.
Nationwide, police departments utilize cameras to amass data on countless vehicles, analyzing these records to retrieve stolen cars, apprehend suspects, or locate missing persons.
The Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department revealed that it operates about 366 stationary license plate readers via Motorola Vigilant and 476 through Flock Safety, used in various contract cities and unincorporated territories. An additional 89 mobile systems are equipped on patrol vehicles.
The department affirmed that its policy denies data sharing with entities that lack a legitimate purpose, emphasizing that any data exchanges with law enforcement occur only through formal agreements ensuring legal compliance. Currently, there are no federal data-sharing agreements.
Tricia McLaughlin from the Department of Homeland Security mentioned that the federal agency has multiple avenues to enforce federal laws in Los Angeles and nationally.
Efforts by local politicians to bar sheriff cooperation with ICE have been branded reckless by McLaughlin, though she admits such actions would not impede ICE’s law enforcement activities.
Agencies like LAPD and others in the Southern California region have faced allegations of violating state regulations by providing license plate data to federal officials. A report highlighted that over 100 data requests were made by local police on behalf of federal bodies in a single month.
Catherine Crump from UC Berkeley's Technology & Public Policy Clinic likened data control challenges to sharing personal data with tech giants who repurpose it for marketing, noting a lack of user knowledge about data usage.
Despite the Board's attempt to curb data exchanges, ensuring ICE's inability to access data remains a formidable challenge, advocates suggest. Private firms in California can still harvest and sell data potentially accessible to ICE.
Dave Maass from the Electronic Frontier Foundation points out that U.S. Customs and Border Protection operates its own readers in Southern California. Even measures preventing sheriff’s departments from data sharing do not guarantee compliance by individual deputies.
The newly passed motion mandates the Sheriff's Department to routinely disclose which agencies have requested license plate data to two oversight bodies — the Office of Inspector General and the Civilian Oversight Commission.
Maass emphasizes the significance of independent oversight in these data request reviews, noting that such a role could have considerable impact.



Leave a Reply