Request for Menendez Brothers’ New Trial Rejected by Judge
The petition set forth by the Menendez brothers for another trial has been rejected by a judge in Los Angeles. According to the judge, fresh evidence introduced by the brothers did not possess enough weight to alter the original verdict that resulted in their life imprisonment.
Judge William Ryan, overseeing the LA Superior Court, dismissed the habeas corpus writ that was presented in May 2023. The brothers had alleged that their father, Jose Menendez, had engaged in sexual abuse, a claim they sought to use as crucial new evidence.
In his written decision, Judge Ryan noted that the new evidence wasn't convincing enough to change the mind of any juror or enough to justify an instruction of imperfect self-defense.
Efforts to reach out for comments from Mark Geragos, the appellate attorney representing the Menendez brothers, are currently underway, as CBS Los Angeles awaits his response.
Among the evidence submitted was a 1988 letter by Erik Menendez to his cousin, alleging that he had been abused during his adolescence by his father. It also included a statement from Roy Rossello, a former bandmate of their father, alleging he was sexually assaulted by Jose Menendez.
The brothers have long contended that their actions were in self-defense, citing ongoing physical, sexual, and emotional abuse inflicted upon them.
The judge added that this new evidence did not offer a strong contribution to the already considered allegations of abuse and hence was not impactful.
The pursuit of the writ of habeas corpus is one of several methods the Menendez brothers are utilizing to seek a change in their fate. Since their conviction in 1996, they have been serving life sentences without the possibility of parole for killing their parents at their Beverly Hills residence.
The brothers have also filed petitions for clemency, which are currently awaiting a decision from Governor Gavin Newsom.
Nathan Hochman, the District Attorney for Los Angeles County, remains firmly opposed to this retrial and has stated that the new evidence presented does not alter the original conclusion. In his words, self-defense was the underlying defense strategy during the trial, which was rejected by the jury as five different state and federal courts have confirmed the convictions.



Leave a Reply