Montana Man Accused of Multiple Fatalities at Bar Now Faces Extra Allegations
A man from Anaconda, Montana, already accused of killing four individuals at a local bar, is now facing extra accusations, among them attempted arson, according to officials on Wednesday.
Judge Jeffrey Dahood from the State District ordered that Michael Paul Brown be detained without the possibility of bail. His defense team argued that mental health concerns could play a crucial role in his legal case.
Brown's family disclosed that the 45-year-old ex-military personnel has long battled mental health issues prior to the alleged incident on August 1, where a bartender and three bar patrons were shot at The Owl Bar in Anaconda.
New legal documents highlight that Brown attempted to set the bar ablaze by igniting items inside. David Gwerder, the bar's owner, shared that the investigators informed him Brown tried to use a flaming cardboard pizza box as a firestarter for a bucket of flammable materials which failed to ignite.
Not long after the failed arson attempt, the suspect allegedly left the scene but returned shortly with a firearm, resulting in multiple casualties.
Walter Hennessey, Brown's lawyer, entered a plea of not guilty on behalf of Brown to numerous charges including four murder counts, theft, and fleeing from law enforcement. The defendant appeared remotely from jail in Butte, Montana.
Brown's bail was initially set at $2 million but has since been denied in favor of keeping him detained, following the prosecution's concerns about public safety and the highlighted mental health issues. His trial is slated for January 12, 2026.
No explanation for Brown’s actions has been formally offered by authorities, and much of the legal proceedings have been kept confidential by the court order.
In Montana, a conviction of deliberate homicide is potentially punishable by the death penalty, though executions have been halted in the state since 2015 due to issues surrounding lethal injection drugs. The decision to pursue the death penalty for Brown has yet to be made, as disclosed by Deer Lodge County Attorney Morgan Smith.
The small town of Anaconda, located approximately 25 miles from Butte and encircled by mountains, houses about 9,000 residents. Following the incident, Brown is alleged to have stolen a vehicle and abandoned it at the base of a nearby mountain before evading capture in the wilderness.
Over the subsequent week, Brown eluded a substantial manhunt involving helicopters, drones, and teams with dogs, until law enforcement found him on August 8 in an empty building near Stumptown.
Investigators continue to explore whether Brown was provided assistance during his time hiding, potentially by associates or local property owners.
Brown was a frequent visitor at The Owl Bar over several decades and reportedly knew the victims, according to Gwerder.



Leave a Reply