Utah's Efforts to Increase Access to Starter Homes: Progress and Challenges
A new residential development by Nilson Homes in Plain City, Utah, features a mix of smaller starter homes alongside larger properties.
PLAIN CITY, Utah — Young couple Miranda and Cole Potokar, aged 23 and 24, frequently discuss with friends the unfortunate timing of their entry into the housing market.
"We joke about it," says Miranda. "Thinking back, I should have skipped learning multiplication tables in third grade and invested in real estate instead!"
As the Potokars reached adulthood in northern Utah, property prices rose significantly, outpacing much of the nation. This trend has been driven by increasing demand, with Utah drawing more newcomers.
The Potokars spent two years in the basement of Miranda's grandparents to avoid paying high rents and to save for a down payment.
After their marriage two years ago, they chose this living arrangement to build their savings. But upon commencing their house hunt last year, they were stunned by the steep prices and rapid sales, even for older homes.
"Just overnight, it would be sold," Cole mentions with a snap of his fingers. "It was an intense market."
Ultimately, they paused their search.
Rising Median Age of First-Time Homebuyers
Families like the Potokars are typical of those Utah Governor Spencer Cox had in mind when he aimed to construct 35,000 affordable starter homes over five years.
"The possibility of owning a home, a quintessential part of the American dream, is slipping out of reach for too many of our young citizens," Governor Cox expressed at a housing summit attended by numerous mayors.
Nationwide, median home prices have surged nearly 50% over five years, with Utah's prices outpacing this average.
This is primarily due to a substantial deficit in housing supply, combined with inflation and rising interest rates, making home mortgages unattainable for many. The median age for first-time homebuyers in the U.S. is now a record 38, compared to 31 a decade ago.
To spur more affordable housing developments, last year Utah legislators introduced incentives to promote the construction of starter homes. This was expanded this year to include condos. However, developer engagement remains limited.
Cox reported to mayors that only around 5,100 starter homes had been built or commenced construction.
"We're progressing, but the pace must quicken," he urged.
The Call for More Comprehensive Reforms
Governor Cox has made affordable housing a focal point of his policy agenda, citing surging costs as a critical threat to the state's economic health.
He advocates for builders to fill this vital market void, even if it doesn't offer the highest profit margins. He urges community leaders to approve projects despite potential local opposition. Cox calls on Utahns to consider the housing needs of future generations, challenging them not to prioritize present comfort over future opportunities.
Yet, experts like Andra Ghent, a University of Utah finance professor, argue that real progress requires significant zoning reforms. This includes reducing restrictive lot size requirements, similar to changes implemented by several states, although such measures have not gained legislative support in Utah.
"Developers constrained by large lot requirements are compelled to build luxury homes," Ghent explains.
A Developer's Perspective: Seizing Opportunity
Developer Jed Nilson, inspired by the governor's initiative, embraced the challenge north of Salt Lake City.
Nilson, who began as a realtor in college, recounts a time when his peers would easily purchase new homes from him.
"It's concerning that dual-income, college-educated couples now struggle to buy," he comments.
Determined to find cost-effective building methods, Nilson aims to make homeownership attainable once more.
When the governor declared the starter-home target, Nilson saw a prospect. Partnering with Weber County, he secured approval to add more houses on smaller lots in his development.
He highlights the initial twelve starter homes built, positioned at the community's entrance next to larger homes, showcasing diverse architectural styles.
Nilson notes a substantial waitlist for these homes, indicative of the demand.
Homes are priced below $400,000, aligning with Governor Cox's target, though still steep by some standards.
Priority is given to first-time buyers, teachers, first responders, and military members, with owner-occupancy required for ten years.
First-Time Homeowners: A New Beginning
The Potokars were among the first to move into their new home this past spring.
Miranda appreciates the spaciousness of their dining area, and Cole praises the large windows that attractively light their 1,400 square-foot, two-story house.
They cherish their morning walks and connecting with similarly aged neighbors, grateful for their new community.
Cole views their home as foundational for their family's future and financial stability.
Nilson plans to expand this model with 260 additional starter homes, hoping his efforts encourage other developers to address the housing gap.
"Building fewer luxury homes for greater societal gain," Nilson concludes, "supports community growth by providing realistic pathways for homeownership and economic mobility."



Leave a Reply