Judge Blocks Trump's Use of National Guard for Law Enforcement in California
A U.S. District Court judge issued a ruling on Tuesday prohibiting President Trump from deploying the National Guard in California for law enforcement tasks such as making arrests, conducting searches, or managing crowds.
This decision arose from a lawsuit that California initiated in early June, challenging the use of National Guard troops ordered by Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to handle protests in Los Angeles related to federal immigration policies.
Judge Charles Breyer determined that the deployment contravened the federal Posse Comitatus Act, which restricts the use of military forces for domestic law enforcement purposes.
Breyer's ruling, which is specific to California, is temporarily held until September 12 to allow the Trump administration the opportunity to appeal.
This decision is set against the backdrop of Trump's consideration of deploying National Guard forces to other cities in the United States to address crime issues, including in Oakland and San Francisco.
Breyer cautioned that such deployments could effectively establish 'a national police force with the President at its helm.'
"In 1878, Congress explicitly mandated the Posse Comitatus Act to forbid the domestic use of the U.S. military for law enforcement," Breyer stated.
He added, "After nearly 140 years, the defendants—President Trump, Secretary Hegseth, and the Department of Defense—sent National Guard and Marine troops to Los Angeles, ostensibly to suppress a rebellion and enforce immigration laws."
The judge noted there were protests in Los Angeles with some instances of violence, but emphasized, "there was no uprising, nor was local law enforcement unable to handle the situation and maintain order."
He highlighted that during the trial, evidence showed that troops, often indistinguishable due to protective gear, and military vehicles were systematically used to establish security perimeters and traffic blocks, engage in crowd management, and otherwise assert a military presence in Los Angeles.
CNBC has asked for a statement from the Justice Department, which defended Trump's actions in the lawsuit, regarding the judge's decision.



Leave a Reply