Shifts in Labor Markets: From the 'Big Stay' to a Stagnant Hiring Freeze
During the Covid-19 crisis, a phenomenon dubbed the "Great Resignation" saw millions abandon their positions. Now, economic insecurity has sparked a new trend: the "Great Stay."
This terminology was introduced to describe a decrease in the number of individuals leaving their jobs, paired with a slowdown in hiring and layoffs.
Nela Richardson, an economist with ADP, highlighted changes in behavior. 'Following the 'Great Resignation,' we're now witnessing a period where employees are remaining in their roles,' she explained to CNBC.
Richardson suggests many workers have settled into positions that suit them, perhaps involving remote work and lucrative salaries. The data now shows historically low job turnover in the United States.
'The 'Great Stay' aptly describes this era,' she continued. 'People are maintaining their positions, notably in fields like IT and software, known for higher turnover rates.'
Similarly, Richardson noted that companies are hesitating to make hiring decisions due to future uncertainties, not necessarily aiming to decrease their workforce.
She described the current climate as a 'no-hire, no-fire market.' Recruitment has slowed, even though U.S. jobless claims, a layoff measure, remain historically low.
'The present environment is one of layoff aversion because rehiring was such a protracted process in the U.S.,' she stated.
The shift from widespread resignations is stark. The pandemic disrupted the longest employment expansion in U.S. history, with 50.5 million resignations in 2022, rising from 47.8 million in 2021.
Signs of a cooling job market are appearing, with nonfarm payroll additions underwhelming at 73,000 in July and unemployment slightly increasing to 4.2%.
Similar Patterns in the UK
The UK mirrors this trend, where job vacancies peaked at 1,172,000 between August and October 2021. By mid-2022, this rose to 1,295,000.
Fast forward to 2025, job openings had declined by 5.8%, settling at 718,000 from May to July across most industries, the ONS reports.
Feedback from surveys suggests a reluctance to add or replace workers. Economic inactivity, reflected by non-seeking individuals aged 16-64, was 21% in mid-2025.
Labor costs from tax hikes and increased minimum wage, coupled with economic unpredictability, have decreased business hiring over the past three years, according to Monica George Michail from the National Institute of Economic and Social Research.
Falling inactivity and rising unemployment have slightly boosted labor supply.
Neil Carberry of the Recruitment and Employment Confederation acknowledges a 'Big Stay' in Britain, with companies cautious about hiring amidst sluggish growth.
'Growth drives job creation,' Carberry told CNBC. 'For businesses to proceed with hiring in the UK, they need a climate conducive to economic expansion.'
He noted that the job market feels stagnant. Though permanent placements have been low for some time, businesses are hesitant, waiting for a boost in confidence to make hiring decisions.



Leave a Reply