Preparing the US Military for Advanced Warfare: Lessons from Ukraine
To truly brace for an impending large-scale conflict, the US military must overhaul its learnings from almost 20 years of engagement in Middle Eastern conflicts, as stated by an American veteran currently serving in Ukraine.
Identified only by his call sign, 'Scooter,' this veteran, who instructs with Ukraine's 4th Ranger Regiment, suggests that Russia's actions offer critical insights for Western nations in prepping for future battles.
In a conversation via video call from an undisclosed place in central Ukraine, he remarked, "The primary lesson for NATO and the US should be to discard their previous war strategies." He emphasized that a counterinsurgency, similar to the strategies employed in Iraq and Afghanistan, starkly contrasts a traditional war in terms of its combat intensity and threat types.
Air Dominance is Crucial
Scooter, previously a US Navy service member, experienced frontline combat alongside foreign volunteers and is now part of Ukraine’s Special Operations Forces. He described the threats they face: helicopter rockets, fighter plane assaults, and precise artillery, pointing out how these pose a different menace compared to Middle Eastern engagements.
Commanders must focus on training their units to handle threats akin to those anticipated during the Cold War era, he articulated, underscoring the need for preparation reminiscent of the 1980s challenges.
In contemporary warfare, achieving dominance in the sky via neutralizing enemy air defenses is paramount. Unlike past Middle Eastern operations, US forces previously had relatively uncontested airspace.
Despite fielding superior air power, Russia's failure to secure aerial dominance early in its invasion demonstrated how such shortcomings could exacerbate battlefield stalemates. This has locked their forces in a grueling, drawn-out engagement.
Adapting to New War Realities
From strategic viewpoints, US and NATO planners understand that neutralizing enemy defenses and claiming airspace control is critical when engaging comparable adversaries like Russia.
Retired US Air Force Gen. James Hecker once noted that lacking air superiority puts forces in peril comparable to current Russian-Ukrainian confrontations known for high casualties.
Scooter advises prioritizing the development of skilled pilots and efficient logistical and maintenance systems, seeing these as crucial for military readiness.
Pragmatism in Combat Training
"In warfare where air power dictates outcomes, ground forces capture and maintain territory," Scooter remarked, emphasizing the difficulty of doing so against adversaries equipped with artillery and air support.
Despite efforts to prepare, guaranteed air superiority isn't always feasible. Temporary gains in airspace control can be pivotal in exploiting battlefield openings, suggested by various military strategists.
Learning Beyond Guides
The insights emerging from Ukraine span beyond high-level strategy, infiltrating down to individual soldier tactics.
For troops, staying nimble and discreet is key. Invisible weaponry and low profiles prevent becoming targets. Speed is a soldier’s ally, explained Scooter: "The faster you move, the longer you survive."
He advocates for American special forces to embrace innovative thinking, diverging from manuals when reality demands quick, adaptive strategies, especially in evacuation operations.
"Ditch the manuals and adapt to the real dynamics," he reiterated, highlighting the gap between training and actual combat realities.
This notion isn't novel among US veterans in Ukraine, with previous servicemen acknowledging the necessity to shift away from counterinsurgency-focused tactics.
Elevating Drone Warfare Awareness
A pivotal focus area for the US military involves aligning itself with rapidly evolving drone warfare. Both Kyiv and Moscow's dynamic drone strategies underscore the urgency for the US to accelerate its drone conflict preparedness.
Analysts have pinpointed the US's current unreadiness for such engagements and stress transformative steps to bolster military capabilities in this arena.



Leave a Reply