Trump's Surprising Assertion of Unchecked Authority
New revelations have emerged regarding President Trump's clandestine move to bypass a national restriction on TikTok, stirring concerns.
As Independence Day neared, it came to light that Donald Trump had clandestinely assumed a power deemed too perilous for even England’s King George. This revelation emerged through identical letters sent out by Attorney General Pam Bondi to ten major tech enterprises on April 5, directing them to disregard the legislative mandate banning TikTok in the U.S.
These correspondences, made public following a Freedom of Information Act request, mainly contain feeble justifications for why these companies could keep featuring TikTok, contrary to explicit legal demands.
When considered collectively, these assertions represent a menacing assertion that the president can bypass legislation for specific businesses if he perceives it as an obstacle to his foreign policy objectives.
Historically known as the 'dispensing power,' this was once a royal prerogative in England, enabling kings to exempt their allies from adhering to laws, which extended beyond foreign affairs. Essentially, it was a form of anticipatory pardon, freeing individuals from adhering to laws without repercussions.
This authoritarian privilege was eradicated by the 1689 English Bill of Rights as it was anti-democratic. In the United States, the Supreme Court nullified a presidential dispensing power in 1838, a ruling widely accepted by scholars today.
The Bondi Letters: A Breach of Legal Norms
Bondi’s communications plainly oppose the foundational constitutional principle that denies such presidential authority.
Legal academic Alan Rozenshtein describes the letters as tantamount to proclaiming an unrestricted dispensing power regarding international matters, a concept he has monitored closely in the TikTok affair.
Outside niche legal forums, these letters have largely gone unnoticed. Yet, Trump’s assertion of a dispensing authority—which includes the ability to authorize unlawful actions—is potentially explosive.
Analyzing Bondi’s Argument for Exceptional Presidential Power
Comprised of only six brief paragraphs, Bondi's letters do not overtly declare a dispensing power. However, they perplexingly intertwine various legal positions without elucidating their integration into a unified rationale.
The core argument appears to hinge on the president's unilateral authority, under Article II of the Constitution, to decide if legislation encroaches upon his responsibilities to safeguard national and international security.
According to Bondi’s logic, if Trump determines that legislation hampers his diplomatic activities, he is at liberty to assure companies or individuals of immunity from prosecution if they deviate from compliance.
Superficially, these claims resemble the president’s normal prerogatives regarding statute contradictions and enforcement discretion. On closer inspection, however, they resonate more with a historical dispensing right.
The judiciary has previously determined that some laws might infringe upon Article II, the most famous case being the 2014 decision to annul a statute regarding passport designations for citizens born in Jerusalem.
Nevertheless, this does not render all legislative limits on presidential foreign policy authority unconstitutional. There is no justifiable argument that the TikTok prohibition violates Article II, as confirmed by a unanimous Supreme Court decision in January.
While presidents do possess discretion in legal enforcement—owing to the disparity between legal infractions and available prosecutorial resources—this discretion can spark contentious debates, as seen during Obama's administration.
However, experts argue that Trump’s TikTok actions differ significantly since enforcement scarcity was never at issue—leading tech giants had already complied by removing TikTok from their marketplaces.
Instead, Trump’s maneuver provided tech giants carte blanche to flout an existing law, effectively reinstating a dispensing power hearkening back to monarchial rule.
The Potential Threat of Trump's Letters
To grasp the letters’ significance, one might draw parallels with presidential pardon power.
The power to pardon is notably susceptible to abuse, as it enables presidents to absolve federal offenses, theoretically prompting individuals to breach laws with promises of clemency afterward.
However, pardoning is limited to criminal offenses. In contrast, legal expert Jack Goldsmith reads Bondi’s letters as suggesting authority to pardon civil transgressions proactively, effectively allowing presidents to sanction illicit activities under the pretext of foreign policy quirks.
Presently, it doesn't seem this logic is being extended beyond enabling corporate contravention of the TikTok ban. Yet, as Goldsmith observes, once such power is exercised successfully, it becomes standard practice for future presidents.
Steve Vladeck, another prominent legal scholar, warns that Bondi’s precedent might pave the way for future authority assertions, with potentially unpopular and corrupt outcomes.
Admittedly, I initially dismissed the legal squabble over TikTok’s legality as minor procedural discord in a legislative process some lawmakers now regret. However, Bondi’s letters urge reconsideration.
The real issue transcends TikTok; it’s about Trump possibly executing a secretive, evidently unconstitutional power conquest—likely evading legal challenges due to procedural hindrances.
This scenario is particularly troubling against the broader backdrop of Trump's agenda.
David Post from the Cato Institute points out that Trump openly displays a willingness to prioritize his desires over constitutional constraints, heightening the gravity of transgressions like voiding federal statutes.



Leave a Reply