Struggles of an Asbestos Illness Clinic Near a Former Montana Mine

Struggles of an Asbestos Illness Clinic Near a Former Montana Mine

Clinic Forced to Close Due to Legal Disputes

The Center for Asbestos Related Disease (CARD) in Libby, Montana, known for offering free lung assessments for conditions linked to asbestos, was recently shut down due to a lawsuit initiated by BNSF Railway, representing the federal government.

At 81, Gayla Benefield navigates her home tethered to an oxygen machine, moving through her living spaces in this secluded town within scenic northwestern Montana.

As a resident of this small mountain community near the Canadian border, Benefield, like many others, suffers from lung scarring caused by asbestos.

Her father worked in a now-defunct mine in Libby, known for producing much of the globe’s vermiculite—a material utilized in insulation and other applications.

The mine's closure in 1990 was shortly followed by the disclosure in 1999 that the extracted vermiculite was tainted with asbestos, explaining the rising cases of illness among Libby’s population.

The memory of her father returning covered in white dust remains vivid for Benefield; later, she realized her family had unwittingly inhaled asbestos, a toxic fibrous substance.

"Over time, the resulting scarring encases the lungs completely," Benefield noted, alluding to the gradual suffocation it causes.

In 2002, sections of Libby gained notoriety when the Environmental Protection Agency identified them as contamination sites.

A groundbreaking public health emergency was declared by the agency in 2009, marking a significant moment in U.S. history.

An investigation revealed that between 1979 to 2011, asbestos-related diseases claimed the lives of 694 individuals in Libby, and health estimates indicate nearly 10% of its residents harbor related illnesses.

This data comes from the CARD Clinic, a registered nonprofit that primarily relies on federal funding for conducting free screenings for local residents.

The clinic screened a significant portion of Libby's populace, addressing symptoms that may not present until decades after exposure.

However, operations have ground to a halt following a court mandate to cease activities after BNSF’s lawsuit in May.

Benefield, part of the team that helped establish the CARD Clinic, expressed regret over previous generations like her parents who suffered without understanding their afflictions.

BNSF pursued the clinic using federal whistleblower laws, aiming to recuperate close to $2.9 million for itself and government court fees by reclaiming the clinic's properties.

Funding Troubles and Legal Challenges

Clinic leaders are actively contesting the court verdict and are eager to reopen, yet financial uncertainties loom large as their main federal funding source also faces risks.

The Trump administration is contemplating cuts to the federal grant that forms the backbone of the clinic’s operational budget.

According to CARD's Executive Director, Tracy McNew, withdrawal of this grant—nearly a $3 million lifeline—might seal the clinic's fate permanently.

Despite a temporary suspension, the grant was reactivated, although White House officials retain the authority to evaluate it for further reductions. CARD continues its legal battles to retrieve its assets taken under BNSF's claims.

Queries regarding grant status from NPR and health news outlets have gone unanswered by key government offices, including OMB and Health and Human Services.

Attorney Tim Bechtold suggested deterring the grant cuts is challenging due to protections under the Affordable Care Act, which entitles Libby asbestos victims to medical and diagnostic aid.

The complications from BNSF's move to seize clinic assets are compounded by a judgment against CARD of approximately $6 million; CARD is fervently appealing this in federal court.

In light of CARD’s closure, patients must find alternatives that may not be readily available, presenting a significant hurdle in obtaining comparable medical assessments.

The Challenges of Diagnosing Asbestos-Related Conditions

Jon Kratzke, an oncologist involved in asbestos-linked cancer research, emphasized the difficulty of diagnosing asbestos-related diseases. Such diagnoses demand medical precision and a deep understanding of the symptoms specific to asbestos exposure.

Professional evaluations require specialists to interpret imaging scans appropriately—a resource previously provided by the CARD Clinic.

Reconstructing CARD’s expertise is a formidable task in Libby, a challenge reiterated by Kratzke given the limited specialist availability, necessary for continued patient monitoring.

Jenan Swenson, Gayla Benefield’s only child yet unaffected by asbestos disease, received her last assessment mere days before the clinic ceased operations.

Swenson believes her own health may soon be compromised due to childhood asbestos exposure, while her role as her mother’s caregiver underscores a dire need for ongoing cancer screenings.

The prospect of needing out-of-state travels for medical care if CARD remains closed is both practical and financial burdens they could barely manage.

"We’re unlikely to be the only ones facing this predicament," Swenson expressed, reflecting the potential plight of numerous Libby families should alternative medical care remain elusive.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts