Wisconsin Supreme Court Overturns Historic Abortion Ban

Wisconsin Supreme Court Overturns Historic Abortion Ban

In a significant judicial move, the liberal faction of the Wisconsin Supreme Court has nullified a century-old abortion prohibition. By a narrow 4-3 margin, the court ruled that the antiquated 1849 statute was effectively overridden by more contemporary regulations that permit abortions up to fetal viability.

Originally enacted in the mid-19th century, the 1849 law classified the act of abortion by anyone other than the pregnant individual as a felony.

This law lay dormant following the 1973 Roe v. Wade verdict, which established a nationwide right to abortion. Although still officially on the books, some conservatives believed the reversal of Roe v. Wade in 2022 reactivated this law.

In response, Wisconsin Attorney General Josh Kaul initiated a legal challenge, asserting the old ban was null due to existing statutes from the Roe era that allowed abortion up to the point a fetus could survive independently, often post 21-week gestation with medical intervention.

The position was contested by Joel Urmanski, Sheboygan County’s District Attorney, who argued the coexistence of past and present statutes, much like varying penalties apply for identical offenses.

In a precedent-setting 2023 judgment, Judge Diane Schlipper from Dane County clarified that the ancient ban was meant to address non-consensual ending of pregnancies and did not apply to voluntary terminations. Consequently, scheduled abortions remained unaffected, a stance solidified by the state Supreme Court's recent decision.

Urged by Urmanski, the state’s highest court swiftly reviewed Schlipper's decision without awaiting intermediary appeals, due to expectations that the liberal-leaning court, which includes justice Protasiewicz vocally supporting abortion rights, would abolish the ban.

The liberal bloc of the court, newly fortified by Susan Crawford's victory over conservative Brad Schimel, secured their 4-3 control through at least 2028. While Crawford's official participation in the decision was pending, her influence is anticipated in an ongoing legal challenge from Planned Parenthood questioning the 1849 law's constitutional validity, an issue the court acknowledged last year but is yet to decide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts