Canada: Echoing American Ideologies More Than the U.S?
Exploring how a 1965 prophetic assertion on Canada's future brings a fresh perspective to Trump's idea of turning Canada into the 51st American state.
The interesting alignment of Canada Day, celebrated on July 1, just before the American Independence Day, has always seemed intriguing to me.
These two national festivities reveal opposing philosophies: Canada Day commemorates the 1867 confederation under British rule, contrasting with America’s July 4 adherence to revolutionary independence from Britain. Historically, the two countries have peacefully coexisted, sharing the world's longest undefended border, making the proximity of these dates feel more like a shared national celebration rather than conflicting ones.
Rekindling Frictions
Nonetheless, Donald Trump managed to stir tensions anew around these holidays.
On the preceding Friday to Canada’s long weekend, Trump escalated the dormant trade war by announcing a cessation of all trade negations with Canada, and promised new tariffs within a week. This declaration was voiced on his platform, Truth Social.
Amplifying the tension, Trump suggested, during a TV interview, that Canada ought to become part of the United States, asserting that the U.S. is indispensable to Canada, whereas the reverse isn't true. This claim was aired in his exchange with journalist Maria Bartiromo.
Perspectives from a Conservative Thinker
Reflecting on Trump's statements, Canadian philosopher George Grant’s insights become particularly enlightening.
In 1965, Grant released 'Lament for a Nation,' predicting that Canada's growing connectivity with the U.S. was tantamount to national self-destruction. He suggested that by aligning closely with a powerful neighbor, Canada compromised its political independence.
Grant perceived this not only as a political hazard but a philosophical one, arguing that such integration drained Canada’s conservative essence, conforming it with America’s relentless fervor for change.
With Trump’s threats looming, Grant’s words appear more prescient than ever, prompting renewed academic debates. Commentators such as Patrick Deneen and Michael Ignatieff—Grant’s relative—have revisited these discussions with fresh eyes given today’s circumstances.
Unexpected Outcomes
Yet, Grant did not foresee the unexpected turn of events. When he envisaged Canada being overtaken by American liberalism, it emerged instead that an uncharacteristically illiberal U.S. leadership now threatens Canadian autonomy.
In response, under Mark Carney’s leadership, the Liberal Party has embodied opposition to American imperialism, affirming Canada’s image as a paragon of diversity and acceptance.
Historical Insights
A pivotal moment in Grant’s book is the 1963 electoral loss of Prime Minister John Diefenbaker, which he saw as Canada’s irreversible capitulation.
Diefenbaker, which in Grant’s narrative, similarly to Trump today, symbolized a resistance to the liberal establishment. Originating from Saskatchewan and embodying prairie conservatism, he was distinct from Canada's political elite, who favoured deeper ties with the U.S.
Unlike them, Diefenbaker emphasized Canadian sovereignty over the economic advantages of American cooperation. He notably opposed deploying American nuclear arms on Canadian territories, fearing eroded national identity.
Grant attributed Diefenbaker's downfall to this resistance against economic and political integration with the U.S. Post his defeat, Grant saw no checks against policies that further knitted the two nations together.
Philosophical Implications
Despite Canada thriving decades later, it seems dismissive to just discount Grant’s warnings as misconceived. His concerns were less about literal annexation and more about Canada surrendering its cultural and political uniqueness to American influence.
Grant saw America as a torchbearer of Enlightenment liberalism, one that dismantles societal constraints to liberate the individual, creating a homogenized, technological world.
Conversely, Canada’s British conservative roots espoused preserving traditions and refining them to measure national character. Grant believed Canadian conservatism, aligned with French Quebec's cultural preservation, countered America's aggressive capitalist evolution.
Resurfacing in Trump’s Era
Fast forward to today’s scenario, Canadian ties with a now openly aggressive U.S. administration under Trump threaten the nation’s independence, validating Grant’s broader fears of continental dependency.
Most Canadians find Trumpian nationalism distasteful, spurring a political pushback led by Canada’s Liberals, not the Conservatives.
Prime Minister Carney capitalized on this sentiment during Canada’s recent elections, contrasting against his Conservative adversary Pierre Poilievre’s Trump-like populism.
Ironically enough, traditional notions of conservatism now mirror American ideals too closely for most Canadians’ comfort, leading to a liberal resurgence.
Over the decades, Canada has embraced its new multicultural identity, thriving even in diversity—an element Grant might view as affirming his anxieties over lost heritage, yet such liberalism enabled modern defenses against U.S. dominance.
The contemporary Canadian identity transcends flags or royalty, underscored by what people hope never becomes the volatile political ethos seen south of the border. Ironically, in some respects, Canadians embody American values of liberty and progress more than Americans themselves. It seems July Fourth started a bit earlier this year.



Leave a Reply