Ranking McDonald's McFlurries from Least to Most Enjoyable
When the weather heats up, visiting a McDonald's drive-thru might be your best way to cool down.
McDonald's has been offering its twist on an ice cream sundae, the McFlurry, since they first appeared in Canada in 1995. Since then, flavors have varied, such as Oreo, M&M, Shamrock Shake, and the newly introduced Hershey’s S’mores.
In a recent effort to be environmentally friendly, the iconic plastic McFlurry cup has been replaced with a paper version, and the hollow spoon is now a standard plastic one.
Introduced on June 10, the Hershey's S'mores flavor invokes memories of nostalgic campfires, yet the taste may not always live up to childhood expectations.
I set out to try all the available McFlurry options at McDonald's to discover which is worth your $3. This is how they stood against each other.
Mini McFlurries for Taste Testing
To compare, I opted for the smaller 4-ounce portion of each McFlurry, priced at $2.99 each, before tax, at a Brooklyn location.
While the regular size offers more bang for your buck at $5.39, I chose the minis to explore each flavor.
The M&M McFlurry – A Distant Last
Decorated with colorful M&Ms, this McFlurry gained a swirled look as they started to melt during my walk.
The M&M McFlurry Fell Short on Flavor
Although the M&Ms added a textural contrast, they didn’t contribute much in terms of taste, lacking a robust chocolate presence.
Despite the creaminess of the vanilla soft serve, the toppings on the other sundaes were preferable.
The Latest Hershey's S'mores McFlurry
Comprising vanilla ice cream mixed with Hershey’s chocolate, graham crackers, and marshmallows, this flavor is available only for a limited period.
A Crunchy, Yet Unbalanced Treat
This choice stood out for its complex flavors, with graham crackers offering crunch and a sweet kick, while chocolate and marshmallows captured the essence of s’mores.
However, the toppings were overly clustered at the top, leaving plain ice cream to navigate afterward.
The Timeless Oreo McFlurry Stands Out
This inaugural McFlurry brings a tried-and-true delight, with classic cookies integrated into soft serve and topped additionally.
A Rich Chocolate Experience
The thorough mix of Oreo pieces ensured a consistent cocoa flavor spread throughout the ice cream.
The ice cream perfectly merged with Oreo chunks, unlike the other options where toppings remained mostly at the top.
My McFlurry of Choice for a Refreshing Treat
Considering flavor and the cost, just under $3, the Oreo McFlurry emerges as a tempting addition for those seeking a sweet reprieve on a budget.
While the other flavors have their charms, Oreo stands out for its full-bodied flavor.



Leave a Reply