Think Your Job is Tough? Try Working in HR

Think Your Job is Tough? Try Working in HR

In the past year and a half, Evan Loveless, who works in human resources, has orchestrated seven separate rounds of layoffs, personally breaking the news to countless colleagues at his advertising firm.

“It's an ongoing state of melancholy because these situations arise frequently for me,” commented Loveless, based in St. Louis. “Imagine being stuck under a perpetual raincloud.”

Loveless recounted an especially devastating conversation with an employee who initially thought he was going to receive a promotion.

“Sometimes, the spouse of the person I’m laying off has also just lost their job,” he noted. “Their expressions linger in my mind like phantoms.”

HR roles have traditionally been far from glamorous, often involving the enforcement of unpopular policies. Today, professionals in this field report that their responsibilities are becoming increasingly unpleasant. Continuous rounds of job cuts, stricter office return policies, workplace immigration scrutiny, and the urgent need to train staff on artificial intelligence are the current challenges burdening HR teams.

“It’s a simultaneous convergence of numerous significant challenges, the scale of which is unprecedented in my over three decades as a human capital expert,” remarked Jim Link, head of HR at the Society of Human Resource Management.

These new pressures follow what was already a difficult phase for HR personnel. During the pandemic, they were tasked with creating and managing remote work environments amid vaccine resistance and societal unrest following George Floyd's murder.

Nowadays, HR departments face even more demands, according to Tracy Brower, a sociologist studying workplace dynamics in Michigan. “The pressure on HR is growing in both scope and intensity,” said Brower.

Concerns About Deportation

Another issue HR is confronting is the effect of heightened immigration enforcement initiated during the Trump era.

Weekly, foreign employees approach Alexandra Valverde, HR director for a food company in the Southeast, expressing worry over potential immigration raids. Many are visibly emotional.

“I've never had a year as tough as this in HR,” shared Valverde, with industry experience dating back to 2019. “The level of fear I’m witnessing among employees—regardless of their actual immigration status—is unprecedented.”

The relentless wave of layoffs is especially daunting for HR personnel dealing with employees on H1-B visas. These visas allow foreign workers to remain in the U.S. temporarily if certain conditions are satisfied.

“Letting someone go is always difficult, but it becomes even more distressing when that employee may be forced to leave the country,” shared Mike Smart, HR executive at a tech firm in California. H1-B visa holders typically have only 60 days to secure another job or face deportation.

“Even in prosperous job markets, 60 days is scarcely enough,” Smart said.

As of May, companies have reported a total of 696,309 job eliminations this year—an 80% surge from the same period last year, per a report from Challenger, Gray & Christmas.

The situation is compounded by executives predicting further layoffs due to the integration of generative AI. Recently, multiple CEOs, including Amazon's Andy Jassy, have indicated that these advances might significantly reduce their workforce.

Facing Heated Reactions

HR specialists are accustomed to absorbing criticism for instituting policies that employees may not appreciate. However, maintaining composure is increasingly challenging in today's environment.

In the second quarter, layoffs led to a 67% rise in workplace incivility compared to companies without such cuts, based on SHRM data. These acts, including silencing and closely monitoring colleagues, were 63% more common in organizations enforcing office returns.

David Gaspin, leading HR for a New York real estate firm, recalled severe verbal backlash from a laid-off colleague, including being labeled “a mere corporate tool” and “a reprehensible person.”

“Hearing such harsh words is never easy,” Gaspin remarked.

Considering the heightened demands, it's unsurprising that interest in HR roles is waning. Indeed data reveal a near 5% drop in HR job searches in the current year's first half compared to 2024.

A LinkedIn study from 2022 noted HR as having the highest resignation rates among all job categories, a trend yet to be updated.

Rebecca Taylor, a former HR professional and podcast co-host, noted that being viewed as the office pariah contributed to her career shift. The breaking point arrived when an ex-employee harassed her parents via phone after being laid off.

“It was frightening,” said Taylor, who uses an alias partly due to that encounter. It raises the question of what lengths angry employees might go to next.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts