Compass Takes Legal Action Against Zillow Over New Listing Policy
Real estate powerhouse Compass has lodged a lawsuit against Zillow, asserting that the company’s new policy breaches antitrust regulations. This contentious rule disallows property listings on Zillow if they have been available on another platform for more than a day before appearing on Zillow.
Introduced by Zillow in April, this rule was enforced starting May 28. Zillow justifies the policy by claiming it guarantees that property listings are accessible to all prospective buyers equally, without exclusive early access through any single entity.
Compass, known for helping clients by listing properties on its platform before they are posted on Zillow and other sites, argues that what it calls the "Zillow embargo" is a breach of federal antitrust statutes. The brokerage accuses Zillow of leveraging its substantial influence in the market to enforce a ban that curtails competition, according to their legal complaint.
Advocating for Consumer Freedom
Robert Reffkin, CEO of Compass, emphasized in a statement that the lawsuit is fundamentally about preserving the rights of consumers. He insisted that no single corporation should be able to exclude agents or listings for not adhering to its business model.
Reffkin compared Zillow's actions to a scenario where a retailer prohibits a seller for initially listing products on their own site, arguing that consumers ought to have the liberty to determine how they market their homes. Compass has enlisted the expertise of Ken Dintzer from Crowell & Moring, a lawyer known for leading the U.S. government's antitrust case against Google, to represent them in this legal battle.
Compass' Marketing Strategy
The litigation also serves to defend Compass' tripartite marketing approach to home listings, which it claims provides superior service to sellers. Initially, properties are listed as "private exclusives" on Compass' proprietary platform, giving its agents the ability to preview the listing with potential buyers.
Subsequently, properties are published as "coming soon" listings on Compass' public website, making them accessible to internet users searching for homes. The strategy concludes by listing the properties on multiple listing services (MLS) and major aggregation platforms like Zillow.
The lawsuit highlights the conflict by stating that whenever a potential buyer uses Compass instead of Zillow for their search, Zillow misses the opportunity to monetize that interaction by charging real estate agents a fee for the leads.
On Market Dynamics
Compass maintains that the three-step listing approach is pivotal to its business, with nearly half of their clients utilizing it during the first quarter. The company contends that in a market characterized by fair competition, products and strategies should succeed or fail on merit rather than being constrained by dominant players like Zillow.



Leave a Reply