The Big Stay: Why Staying Put is Benefiting Workers More Than Job Switching
In recent times, the trend known as the Big Stay has gained momentum, leaving behind the fear of missing out (FOMO) from the Great Resignation era.
Interestingly, wage growth for employees remaining with their current employers has now overtaken the earnings increases for those transitioning to new jobs. This reversal is quite significant since it hasn't been observed continuously since 2009. Last year in July, job changers seemed to have the upper hand, enjoying an 8.5% growth compared to 5.9% for stayers. However, this has flipped due to companies' reduced urgency to hire, allowing them to offer less attractive incentive packages.
Those sticking with their employers are now leading the charge in wage gains, effectively forming an elite group within white-collar sectors that have seen strong wage rises. Meanwhile, employees who jumped ship during the Great Resignation and managed to hold onto their positions are reaping the benefits of having secured competitive salaries.
Conversely, white-collar professionals currently seeking employment face challenging conditions, as business hiring rates are near their lowest since 2014, not counting the early pandemic period. This situation has prompted a common question: Is now a strategic time to look for a new job?
Cory Stahle from Indeed's Hiring Lab suggests that taking a new job is worthwhile if it offers substantial career advancement and a solid salary increase. Otherwise, staying put might still provide worthwhile financial returns and a degree of stability.
The Rise of the White-Collar Elite
Unlike the Great Resignation phase, where job stayers potentially missed out on higher pay by not changing companies, those who have remained are now seeing the advantages. Recently, industries where white-collar workers prevail have witnessed impressive wage hikes. For example, annual wages in sectors like communications and data services rose by 6%, while business management and related services saw about a 5% rise.
Research from the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta indicates that wage increases for workers staying at their current jobs have consistently outpaced those of job hoppers since February.
Job Seekers Facing Tough Choices
The appealing conditions for current employees contrast sharply with the plight of job seekers. Employers remain cautious, preferring to maximize the skills of their current team instead of venturing to recruit externally. This reluctance creates fewer openings for job seekers who now encounter stiffer competition for available roles.
Daniel Zhao from Glassdoor highlights that the job market has become more difficult, with some workers opting for roles with less pay, particularly in the tech industry.
This trend partly stems from a wave of layoffs, compelling displaced workers to accept jobs with reduced salaries or lower status.
Guy Berger from the Burning Glass Institute notes that the combination of limited job openings and an increase in educated candidates intensifies the competition.
There's speculation that in certain areas, the integration of AI might be reducing demand for white-collar roles, though this impact might not be as significant as assumed.
Professional services maintain a steady hiring demand, though not at the peaks seen in late 2021. The information sector has seen a slight uptick in hiring rates but still lags behind other fields. Meanwhile, job opportunities in financial services remain less abundant compared to other sectors.
Aspiring workers are recalibrating their expectations—the lowest wage people are willing to accept dropped from $82,000 in late 2024 to $74,000 by March 2025. College graduates, too, have adjusted their benchmarks downward during this period.
Even though more graduates are entering non-degree-requiring roles, financial and tech industries continue to attract due to their career advancement potential, albeit now less accessible than before due to a sluggish hiring climate.



Leave a Reply