Trump's IRS Strategy: Echoing Nixon's Controversial Tactics
President Donald Trump has threatened to revoke tax exemptions from Harvard University and various other non-profit entities. This is part of a broader attempt by the president to wield influence over the tax agency.
Trump's approach includes a range of strategies, from using tax records to trace undocumented immigrants, to revoking the tax privileges of institutions like Harvard for political ends—reminiscent of Richard Nixon's historical misuse of the IRS.
These actions are not without precedent. Over 40 years ago, President Richard Nixon attempted to leverage the IRS to penalize adversaries and support allies.
Joseph Thorndike, a tax historian at Tax Analysts, notes that Nixon pondered threatening university tax exemptions. This is strikingly similar to contemporary headlines concerning Trump's intentions.
Nixon's discontent with universities arose from their failure to suppress Vietnam War protests. Similarly, Trump has voiced displeasure with Ivy League institutions for not curbing protest activities related to the conflict in Gaza, amidst his administration's tougher stance on campus antisemitism.
On social media, Trump has boldly declared intentions to remove Harvard's tax-exempt status, asserting that it is deserved.
Despite legislative measures introduced post-Watergate to curb presidential manipulation of the tax agency, Trump seems to be employing tactics from Nixon's repertoire.
IRS Safeguards Imposed by Congress
Audio recordings from 1971 reveal Nixon's attempts to place a loyalist at the helm of the IRS to enact his directives.
Nixon sought a nominee he described in unflattering terms, emphasizing the need for compliance to target political foes while sparing allies.
Despite some setbacks, Nixon was determined to misuse the IRS, highlighting Congress's post-Nixon interest in preventing similar executive overreach.
Subsequent to Nixon's departure, legislation was crafted to shield the IRS from political intrusion, protections now being challenged under the Trump administration.
Tax Data Shared Beyond the IRS
Laws introduced by Congress have imposed strict boundaries on who can access tax information filed with the IRS.
Recently, an agreement was made for sharing taxpayer data with immigration authorities, aiming to locate and expel individuals residing illegally in the U.S.
Immigration advocates are seeking judicial intervention to prevent these data exchanges with other government bodies.
A Treasury Department spokesperson justified this data-sharing as an effort to dismantle information barriers, though critics argue these barriers are essential post-Nixon safeguards.
Mike Kaercher from New York University explains that such data sharing could heighten the risk of politicized IRS actions.
After this agreement, the acting IRS commissioner resigned, marking the fourth leadership change in Trump's short tenure. His choice for permanent commissioner is still pending confirmation.
IRS as a Political Tool
Legislation was passed to deter presidents from engaging in the IRS's investigative processes, reminiscent of Nixon's enemies list debacle.
Former IRS employee Mike Kaercher explains that IRS staff are obligated to report illegal political requests to the inspector general immediately.
Trump persists in advocating for the IRS to terminate tax exemptions for non-profits like Harvard, potentially inciting an inquiry.
Stripping these exemptions would severely impact organizations reliant on tax-free donations and endowment.
Although Nixon's IRS maneuvers were clandestine, Trump publicly outlines his intentions on platforms like social media.
Thorndike observes that Trump's transparency about influencing the IRS is notably bold, albeit arguably ill-advised.
Though Trump denies direct involvement in the push against Harvard, Democrats have requested an inquiry by the IRS inspector general.
NPR's attempts to obtain a statement from the inspector general were not successful.
Kaercher remarks on the disturbing nature of any potential IRS law breaches meant to prevent its usage as an administrative weapon.
Weakened IRS Enforcement Capacity
While the administration urges IRS investigations into specific entities, it simultaneously restricts the agency's overall auditing capabilities.
Significant staff reductions have occurred at the IRS, particularly among tax auditors, threatening the agency's efficacy.
These reductions could negatively affect the federal budget since effective tax enforcement typically results in significant recouped revenue.
Thorndike insists on the importance of a well-resourced IRS for the public good, warning that cuts to staffing levels will ultimately burden taxpayers.




Leave a Reply