I'm an Interior Designer Who Evaluated Holiday Decor at West Elm and Crate & Barrel: One Stood Out for Its Festive Appeal

As a professional in interior design, my expertise is invaluable during holiday decorating seasons.

Although cost-effective decor is my usual choice, the allure of what renowned upscale retailers presented this season piqued my curiosity.

While exploring stores in New York City, I decided to compare the offerings of West Elm and Crate & Barrel—both distinguished for their trendy home furnishings.

Crate & Barrel: A Modern Yet Modest Entrance

Upon entering Crate & Barrel, the ambiance was more serene than exuberant, yet the simplicity was endearing.

The decor at first appeared sleek and understated. The entrance showcased a straightforward festive arrangement with greenery and lights. Large shelves were adorned with white and clear trees, miniature houses, and reindeer, with minimal color present.

Inside, the holiday decor was diffused throughout the store. Finding elements that truly captured the festive spirit required a closer look.

West Elm: Stepping Into Holiday Comfort

Conversely, stepping into West Elm felt like entering a holiday haven.

Immediately greeted by lavishly decorated trees with ornaments in silver, red, and gold, West Elm exuded a warm, inviting atmosphere.

The store's entrance was cozy and festive with gentle lighting, sparkling decor, and holiday-themed arrangements.

Crate & Barrel: Minimalistic Holiday Tables

As I navigated through Crate & Barrel, I observed table displays that embodied simplicity and elegance.

Neutral colors dominated, with white napkins, subtle table runners, and plain glassware. This understated style is ideal for those who appreciate clean lines that extend beyond December.

West Elm: A Warm and Inviting Tablescape

West Elm's tablescapes embraced deeper, more inviting hues.

With festive napkins, gold elements, and lively centerpieces, these settings appeared ready for holiday gatherings.

The vibrant displays projected a warmth that felt at home. One setup featured mauve trees and glittery placemats, seamlessly transitioning between Christmas and New Year celebrations.

Crate & Barrel: Subdued Holiday Throws and Pillows

Crate & Barrel also showcased a selection of cozy blankets and pillows, sprinkled around the floor.

I was particularly fond of the understated holiday accents, such as simple reindeer patterns on beige pillows.

These subtle accessories offered a way to infuse holiday spirit into a home, sans the loudness of traditional red and green.

West Elm: Vibrant and Enthusiastic Throws

In stark contrast, West Elm's throw pillows stood out with their vibrant color schemes.

While some designs were more subdued, the majority embraced bold holiday colors. A particular favorite was a green pillow with quirky depictions of Santa, embodying festive fun.

Unique Stocking Options Only at West Elm

Some of my cherished discoveries were the stockings at West Elm, blending modern lines with classic motifs and hints of color.

They represented a contemporary take on the traditional stocking, whereas Crate & Barrel lacked a robust selection, offering only a small decorative piece.

Broad Selection of Ornaments in Both Stores

Each store boasted a notable array of ornaments, from glass Santas to picture frames and other time-honored designs.

West Elm: Adding a Playful Touch to Ornaments

Although both stores carried traditional ornament designs, West Elm offered a few whimsical ones.

Squirrel-shaped glass ornaments at West Elm were a delightful find, ending up as part of our purchase for family decor.

West Elm: Delivering a True Holiday Experience

Despite both stores displaying beautiful holiday decor, West Elm captivated me with a wider range of classic, cozy decorations.

While Crate & Barrel showcased modern elegance, it lacked the festive charm that West Elm so effortlessly provided.

For those aiming to craft a warm, charming holiday setting, West Elm is your destination. However, ifyour preference leans toward a more subtle and neutral holiday look, Crate & Barrel might be more fitting.