Book Extract: "There Is No Place For Us" by Brian Goldstone
Renowned journalist Brian Goldstone, with contributions to notable publications such as The New York Times and Harper's, spent several years investigating the plight of working individuals with low incomes who find themselves without homes in America. In his compelling new book, published by Crown, he delves into the systemic issues impacting the working poor.
The excerpt provided here centers on a character named Celeste—a pseudonym used by Goldstone—navigating the complex and often daunting bureaucratic landscape in her quest for housing in Atlanta.
Arriving early in the morning near Gateway, Celeste was met with long lines, formed by individuals vying for housing assessments offered on a first-come basis. Despite the intimidating scene and aggressive interactions among some in line, she remained resolute, clutching a folder of paperwork imperative for her assessment.
Recent health challenges and financial constraints had eliminated the possibility of securing a long-term housing solution independently. This daunting reality pushed Celeste towards seeking state aid, relinquishing pride in exchange for potential support.
Inside Gateway, after a prolonged wait amidst a diverse group of individuals in a utilitarian space, Celeste was directed to a caseworker who would administer her housing assessment. The questions posed were standard yet felt invasive, probing into health and personal circumstances.
Despite sharing her pressing need due to a recent cancer diagnosis, Celeste was informed that her situation did not score high enough on the assessment tool to qualify for aid based on the standardized evaluation known as the VI-SPDAT.
The assessment criteria dictated that only those deemed "literally homeless," such as individuals in shelters or on the streets, could receive assistance. Celeste, alongside many others in less visible forms of homelessness, found herself trapped by this narrow definition.
Reflecting on the larger issue, advocacy groups argue against this limited definition, noting its failure to acknowledge those in precarious living situations. The impacts of unstable housing on families mirror the vulnerabilities of street homelessness, affecting children's educational and developmental prospects.
Facing Institutional Barriers
In a conversation with a caseworker, Celeste learned that accessing a family shelter was fraught with challenges, particularly with a teenage son. She faced the impossible choice of potential separation, an option she promptly rejected.
As Celeste exited the building, she observed the line of hopeful individuals stretching out as long as when she had arrived. Her story reflects a broader systemic failure, exposing the gaps in existing support systems for those who don't fit neatly into bureaucratic categories.



Leave a Reply