A Glimpse into ‘1929’ by Andrew Ross Sorkin

A Glimpse into '1929' by Andrew Ross Sorkin

Andrew Ross Sorkin, a financial expert associated with The New York Times, presents his new book, '1929', which revisits the most devastating collapse in the history of Wall Street.

Enjoy an intriguing snippet from the book below.

Charles Mitchell approached the entrance of 55 Wall Street with determination, striving to exude his typical air of confidence. It had been a particularly strenuous day. Returning to his workspace, Mitchell was acutely aware of all the eyes watching him—everyone from traders on the street to his own secretary was trying to interpret every expression on his face.

Decked out in a gray three-piece suit and upright posture, Mitchell maintained a steady demeanor as he proceeded through the vast central hall of National City Bank. The institution, adorned with an eighty-three-foot ceiling and massive bronze doors guarding a safe, reigned as the largest bank in the nation.

It was slightly past 5:30 p.m. on Monday, October 28, 1929. The stock market had just experienced an unprecedented 13% drop following a turbulent week. Downtown was still bustling with worried brokers, messengers, and typists, all speculating on the plummeting market. The question on everyone’s mind: What sparked the drop? And could tomorrow bring further turmoil?

As Mitchell strode into his office, reflections in the bank's teller windows betrayed his eye bags and ruffled hair. He sank into a chair behind his stately mahogany desk, which resembled the office of an eighteenth-century leader. Portraits of George Washington flanked the room, symbolizing the leadership qualities Mitchell aspired to.

Known as 'Sunshine Charlie' for his optimism, Mitchell, a bank chairman in excellent shape despite being in his fifties, spent his day in frantic discussions at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, strategizing to stabilize the market. This was a challenge he thought himself suitably prepared for, given his experience and nerve.

Even so, Mitchell felt exposed and vulnerable. He had no time to reflect, as he needed to discuss urgent matters upstairs with Hugh Baker, manager of the bank’s stock-trading unit.

Baker, a tall, clear-eyed figure, reported with an air of calm abstraction about the day’s occurrences while Mitchell was at the Federal Reserve, specifically noting, 'Our bank’s holdings of National City Bank stock have enormously increased.'

Realizing the gravity, Mitchell listened. Baker elaborated, 'We acquired roughly seventy thousand shares.'

Mitchell, adept at mental calculations, quickly grasped the magnitude of the situation. This was overwhelming—the bank lacked the capital to cover such a purchase. His anger and fear spiked; everything he had achieved was now precariously positioned on the edge of ruin.

A month earlier, Mitchell had been triumphantly secure, having orchestrated a takeover of Corn Exchange Bank—a move that would not only make National City the largest bank domestically but globally, surpassing even London’s giant institutions.

However, achieving this required gambling heavily on the value of his own stock. Shareholders of the Corn Exchange were given a choice: accept $360 in cash per share or obtain four-fifths of a share in National City Bank. The stock option was superior, provided National City’s stock remained above $450, hovering comfortably at $496 when the deal was planned. Success depended on the stock maintaining this value, as the bank lacked the liquidity to honor cash payouts—a fact Mitchell kept confidential.

Hence, Mitchell discreetly instructed traders to scoop up shares of National City each time prices sagged.

Under normal conditions, this maneuver was relatively risk-free. However, in a rapidly declining market, such buybacks could rapidly incinerate funds. That afternoon reflected precisely this risk, with National City inadvertently agreeing to purchase over seventy-one thousand shares—a sum far beyond its capability to retain.

"I could be easily toppled by this revelation," Mitchell confided to Baker.

Options were grim. Operational funds for large banks required constant borrowing against assets, but use of their own stock as collateral was prohibited by banking rules. Those acquired shares, costing approximately $32 million, had become a potential threat to National City’s stability.

Mitchell commented on the repercussions of attempting to use those stocks as collateral at other banks, recognizing that rivals might interpret it as a sign of impending trouble. Meanwhile, short sellers poised to exploit sinking stocks posed another worry in this unstable market.

The market was teetering on a knife-edge. Trading volume was so overwhelming that, just the previous Thursday, the ticker reporting stock prices lagged by four hours—a record delay.

This delay rendered the giant price board at the New York Stock Exchange misleading. Trading in this environment was like guessing the outcome of a sports game with a scoreboard left stagnant several innings prior, while those around you gave contradicting insights on the status. Off-exchange trades and their delayed updates exacerbated the chaos. Thus, many traders saw selling as the quickest exit.

Mitchell realized that if he decided to sell even a small portion of the National City shares, rumors about the bank's financial health would ignite, potentially spiraling into an unstoppable cycle. A swift drop in stock prices could incite a massive crisis: "Lack of confidence could lead to bank runs," he considered, picturing depositors queuing at all fifty-eight of their branches across the nation.

A run on the largest bank in the country—a scenario that struck dread into the hearts of bankers everywhere.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts