Our Journey from Careers to True Crime Podcast Success and Breaking a Major Murder Case

Áine Cain and Kevin Greenlee turned their shared passion for true crime into a thriving podcast that replaced their professional lives. Their endeavor reached its zenith with groundbreaking news on the notorious Delphi murder case.

Over four years, they devoted themselves to untangling the mysteries behind the Delphi murders, producing numerous podcast episodes, unveiling breaking news, and eventually publishing a nonfiction crime book on the subject.

Their commitment led them through rigorous conditions during a month-long murder trial. They braved the outdoors, often forgoing basic comforts like food, water, or rest, to be present every day at the hearings. In an era of shrinking media, their podcast emerged as a pivotal source of information on the case.

A Serendipitous Meeting and a Lifelong Partnership

Kevin, an Indiana-based lawyer, noticed Áine, a New York journalist, preserving reports on a cold case both were investigating. What began as a professional interest developed into friendship and eventually love.

Transitioning from separate lives, they launched 'The Murder Sheet' podcast from a modest NYC apartment, initially attracting a small audience. However, their dedication paid off as interest in their meticulous approach grew over time.

The Road to Full-Time Podcasters

Launching a podcast is straightforward, but establishing a livelihood from it proves challenging, given the vast number of podcasts available today. Initially, the couple did not focus on monetization, prioritizing ethical storytelling instead.

By their third year, the growing listenership and income enabled them to pursue their podcast full-time, overcoming financial fluctuations inherent in ad-supported media.

Tackling the Delphi Murder Case

In early 2021, the couple relocated to Indiana and engaged deeply with the Delphi community to gather insights about the brutal murders of Abby Williams and Libby German, two young girls whose tragic end was caught, in part, on video.

Their endeavors culminated in 2022 with the arrest of a suspect, Richard Allen. Covering the trial required extensive personal sacrifices, reinforcing their dedication to truth and justice.

Recording Every Moment

The couple endured long, harsh hours to ensure courtroom access, sacrificing meals and warmth, buoyed by the dedication to provide crucial trial coverage that elevated 'The Murder Sheet' in popularity.

The Book: A Testament to Their Work

Following the verdict, Áine and Kevin condensed their findings into 'Shadow of the Bridge,' granting unique insights into the case's key players and developments, all while processing last-minute details gained during the trial.

Despite its non-lucrative nature, the book served their mission: to amplify the true narrative of the case and honor those affected by its ramifications.

Reflecting on Their Legacy

Their work with 'The Murder Sheet' and their subsequent book highlight the human stories within crime, inspiring both renewed faith in justice and personal growth from shared trials.

Aspiring to continue exploring true crime with empathy and detail, they aim to fill bookshelves with future works, committed to their collective passion for storytelling.