Judge Rules Los Angeles Federal Prosecutor Served Illegally
A ruling by a federal judge on Tuesday stated that the acting head prosecutor for the Justice Department in Los Angeles had been serving in violation of the law for several months. This is a continuation of the legal opposition faced by the Trump administration over its appointments of temporary prosecutors.
U.S. District Judge Michael Seabright's decision affects Bill Essayli, who was the acting chief at the Justice Department in California's Central District. Essayli was involved in a case against three individuals charged with firearm-related offenses. Seabright dismissed the request to drop these charges, emphasizing Essayli's unauthorized role.
Essayli, who previously served as a California state legislator from the Republican party, was appointed as temporary U.S. attorney in April. This interim position generally has a 120-day limit. Before this period expired, Essayli stepped down but was immediately appointed by then-Attorney General Pam Bondi as the first assistant U.S. attorney. According to federal statutes, this position automatically elevates to acting chief when the main office is unoccupied.
Judge Seabright's ruling declared this move invalid, stating that only an existing first assistant U.S. attorney at the time of vacancy is eligible to ascend to the acting chief role.
"In straightforward terms, Essayli assumed the acting United States Attorney role for the Central District of California without legal authorization. He has been holding this post unlawfully since resigning the interim position on July 29, 2025," Seabright declared. "Essayli is barred from carrying out the duties and responsibilities of the U.S. Attorney as acting chief."
Although disqualified from his interim position, Essayli will continue his duties as the first assistant U.S. attorney.
In various states, under the Trump administration, acting federal prosecutors had been left in temporary roles for extended periods. Critics argued this was an attempt to circumvent the Senate—responsible for confirming permanent U.S. attorneys—and the judicial system, which can authorize extensions for temporary appointments under specific circumstances.
Bill Essayli's situation mirrors that of two other acting U.S. attorneys—one in New Jersey and another in Nevada—who have been similarly disqualified. However, Nevada's case saw a stay on the ruling pending an appeal.
Further challenging temporary appointments, former FBI Director James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James have contested the appointment of Lindsey Halligan as acting U.S. Attorney in Virginia's Eastern District.



Leave a Reply