Guidance for California Residents When City Trees Cause Property Damage

Guidance for California Residents When City Trees Cause Property Damage

As California heads into its stormy season, concerns rise among locals, especially with the aftermath of devastating wildfires in the previous years, leaving areas susceptible to falling trees maintained by the municipalities.

In response to damages caused by city trees, the city of Los Angeles has paid out over $18 million since 2021. Unfortunately, getting compensation isn't always straightforward, as discovered by one Burbank resident.

Angela Towne experienced this dilemma firsthand when a city tree collapsed on her car back in March 2024, causing substantial damage. Despite having initiated a claim promptly, she remains embroiled in a legal tug-of-war for reimbursement.

Reflecting on her ordeal, Towne expressed confusion about why resolving the issue has been her burden, especially since the tree was visibly in poor condition, something she insists should not have been overlooked.

A Lone Battle for Compensation

Despite securing a win in small claims court, the city of Burbank appealed, prolonging the legal battle. Facing city attorneys citing adverse weather conditions of the day, Towne ultimately lost, as the city claimed an 'act of God' defense.

Records reveal that since early 2021, Burbank has been hit with 188 such claims, with only a fraction leading to settlements.

Navigating the Claims Process

Allen Carnegie, an attorney with expertise in such disputes, mentions that cities commonly deny liability, attributing incidents to weather. He notes, however, that a lack of maintenance can hold a city accountable if negligence is proven.

Towne claims to have notified the authorities when the tree's health raised concerns months prior to the incident, but her calls went unanswered. Carnegie advises documenting any tree-related worries with evidence, such as photographs, and ensuring all complaints are formalized in writing.

Seeking Professional Assistance

Carnegie also suggests consulting an arborist if a tree’s condition deteriorates, and pursuing legal counsel if litigation becomes necessary. Despite losing her case, Towne might have found success with professional legal representation.

The Endurance of Legal Challenges

Towne, unable to refile her lawsuit due to its conclusion in small claims court, also faces potential denial from her insurance provider due to the time elapsed since the incident.

Expressing relief that no one was harmed, Towne hopes that Burbank city officials will proactively manage such risks before injuries occur.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts