Court Declares Dogs as Cargo for Airline Accountability
According to a ruling by the highest court in the European Union, dogs transported in an airplane's cargo section are classified as luggage. Consequently, airlines are not compelled to provide higher compensation if a pet goes missing.
This ruling arose from a conflict between Iberia, a Spanish airline, and a customer whose dog, Mona, vanished prior to a scheduled flight from Buenos Aires to Barcelona in October 2019.
Mona, due to her size and weight, had to be placed in a pet container in the plane's cargo area. Unfortunately, she escaped during the transfer to the aircraft and was never located.
As described by her owner, Grisel Ortiz, Mona evaded capture across the airport's runway while being pursued by three vehicles, an event witnessed by Ortiz's mother from inside the airplane.
"Many do not grasp what Mona meant to me and find it amusing," said Ortiz in an interview with the Argentine newspaper, Clarin, in January 2020.
Ortiz expressed her profound sadness, stating, "Ever since she vanished, I’ve been on the verge of tears, constantly hoping for a miracle on my phone."
Pursuit of Justice
Ortiz resorted to social media, creating a Facebook page to gather information about Mona and pledging a monetary reward, but no substantial leads surfaced. She also filed a claim with Iberia, seeking 5,000 euros (approximately $5,400) in damages.
Iberia acknowledged their responsibility but insisted that compensation should align with the lower limit applicable to checked luggage as determined by the Montreal Convention, a treaty that regulates airline liabilities.
The Spanish court managing the case referred the question to the European Union Court of Justice, which ruled in favor of the airline.
Understanding Baggage Definition
The court in Luxembourg explained that while the term 'baggage' usually pertains to inanimate objects, it does not necessarily exclude animals from the classification.
According to the court, animals can be classified as 'baggage' for liability considerations as long as their welfare during transport is taken into account.
The judgment observed that Ortiz hadn't filed a 'special declaration of interest' at check-in, which allows for increased compensation for an extra charge, contingent upon airline approval.
Carlos Villacorta Salis, Ortiz's attorney, dismissed this reasoning as flawed, pointing out that it's impractical because no airline would agree to such terms for pets transported via airplane hold.
Salis shared his discontent with the decision, considering it a missed chance to highlight the rights of animals and their owners.
Global Context
The verdict from the European Union’s Court is not final, leaving the Spanish court to determine the compensation outcome.
There have been similar incidents worldwide, some with more favorable conclusions. For example, in 2024, a dog in France, after its fugue from a plane grounded two airport runways, was eventually found after a nine-day search near Paris Charles de Gaulle Airport.
In another incident in September 2023 in the U.S., a dog named Maia escaped her carrier on a runway at Atlanta's airport while being transferred between flights after her owner was detained. After 22 days, she was finally retrieved safely from the airport tarmac.



Leave a Reply