L.A. Police Commission Seat Retained Without Vote

L.A. Police Commission Seat Retained Without Vote

Despite his polarizing presence, Erroll Southers will maintain his role on the Los Angeles Police Commission, as the City Council did not cast an official vote concerning his position.

Known for his previous tenure as the head of the commission overseeing the LAPD, Southers has attracted criticism for allegedly being too lenient with the police chief, Jim McDonnell. Furthermore, his past academic endeavors in Israeli counterterrorism have come under renewed examination.

Typically, nominees for city commissions require City Council approval within 45 days of their nomination. Southers, nominated by Mayor Karen Bass in mid-August, missed the first voting opportunity due to travel. Subsequent meetings omitted him from the agenda without reasoning.

With the 45-day timeframe expired, city protocols now permit Southers to continue in his capacity by default, potentially serving a full five-year term, as he was already an interim appointee.

Speculations have arisen at City Hall regarding the council’s inaction. Some suggest it was a result of scheduling errors, while others believe there was doubt about securing sufficient support for Southers.

Neglecting to vote on such a prominent commission member is nearly unprecedented, according to Zev Yaroslavsky, a former councilman and L.A. County supervisor.

He stated, 'Confirming or rejecting appointments is a council responsibility. It baffles me why someone would strive so hard to be elected only to bypass crucial votes impacting the community.'

Police Commissioner's Role

As bodies akin to corporate boards, police commissioners direct the LAPD's policy implementation, budget approval, and oversee critical matters such as reviews of officer-involved shootings.

In 2025’s initial nine months, LAPD officers have discharged their firearms 31 times, exceeding the total instances from the prior year.

Southers' appointment as interim member began in 2023, when he filled a vacated role on the commission under Mayor Bass.

From his background as an FBI agent to a security leader at USC, Southers played an integral part in searching nationwide for McDonnell's successor as LAPD chief. Both men previously led the Safe Communities Institute at USC.

Supporters and Detractors

Advocates of Southers argue he has dedicatedly engaged with the community to understand desired police chief traits, frequently attending recruitment and graduation ceremonies for the LAPD.

A mayoral spokesperson, Zach Seidl, commended Southers for his adept management of the commission, emphasizing his extensive insight into police operations and his commitment to fostering transparency and community trust.

However, Southers faces significant opposition for his continued involvement, particularly due to his mid-2000s work in Israel, which has become contentious amid the ongoing Gaza conflict.

Controversy and Criticism

His writings are scrutinized by critics who allege they could inform extremist profiling based on controversial public expressions, potentially suppressing minority voices.

Previously, Southers took leave following backlash from his part in handling pro-Palestinian demonstrators on USC premises.

Furthermore, his detractors argue Southers inadequately held McDonnell accountable, with recent calls for imposing stricter oversight on officer conduct during protests and media interactions.

The commission has sanctioned a report covering police violence incidents, but this action fell short for civil rights advocate Greg 'Baba' Akili, who has often opposed Southers.

Akili contended that as commission leader, Southers tended to curtail public discourse more than challenger departmental narratives.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts