Trump's H-1B Visa Policy: Potential Job Losses Instead of Gains
Increasing the expense of acquiring H-1B visas may not necessarily result in a heightened interest in domestic workers by employers.
This is a potential consequence following the Trump administration's move to hike the cost of these sought-after visas—designed for specialized talent not readily available within the United States—to $100,000, according to research experts discussing the matter with Business Insider.
Faced with inflated costs for hiring international workers, some American enterprises might resort to hiring remote employees from overseas as opposed to domestic recruitment. Such a development would not benefit the U.S. labor landscape.
Moreover, the U.S. economy could be damaged by a reduction in skilled foreign labor—impacting general innovation—which in turn could suppress national growth and reduce job vacancies, these experts caution.
This outcome contradicts the intentions of President Donald Trump, whose stated goal is to encourage firms to prioritize American workers over foreign ones.
A White House representative, Taylor Rogers, indicated that the president’s measures are intended to stop businesses from exploiting the system to reduce American wage standards.
"No economic research can negate the real-life impact felt by Americans nationwide who have endured substantial misuse of the H-1B framework," Rogers conveyed in an email to Business Insider.
Adjustments to the H-1B visa rules are expected to have widespread effects throughout the economy as U.S. companies currently utilize the program to hire up to 85,000 international employees annually.
Business Insider sourced opinions from five labor market specialists regarding the effects of increased visa fees.
Offshoring Intensification?
Research largely reveals that imposing visa constraints doesn’t lead to increased local hiring, according to Britta Glennon, a management professor at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School, in a discussion with Business Insider.
Several U.S. multinationals have already adopted offshoring strategies, she noted. With H-1B alterations, these strategies are likely to ramp up.
"Without a compelling reason to stay domestically, companies likely will offshore roles," Glennon stated, referencing global corporations.
For every unissued H-1B visa, major U.S. enterprises with foreign operations hired over 0.4 workers abroad. For firms predisposed to supporting overseas operations, this figure nearly doubled.
Glennon indicated that companies seldom hire one domestic worker for every unutilized H-1B position.
Foreign Labor and Domestic Economic Demand
The common belief is that the U.S. job market is static, says Glennon. Conversely, an influx of foreign talent often stimulates job growth due to increased economic demand.
The result can frequently be a net rise in jobs, instead of a zero-sum situation where a foreign worker replaces a U.S. worker.
"A sort of economic multiplier effect is in play," Glennon remarked.
She mentioned that the revisions to the H-1B program are likely to disadvantage businesses like startups and academic institutions which cannot compete with tech and financial giants that heavily depend on these visas.
According to 2024 statistics from the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, H-1B workers have a median income of $120,000, doubling that of the overall U.S. workforce median wage.
Madeline Zavodny from the University of North Florida cautioned that decreased reliance on H-1B visas could lower demand for positions that cater to these workers, encompassing support roles in HR, marketing, and IT sectors.
"Americans should be exceptionally wary," Zavodny stressed.
Zavodny further stated some early-career roles might permit the substitution of American employees when H-1B visas are unavailable, yet this visa usually fosters more employment rather than taking away local jobs.
Glennon highlighted extensive studies demonstrating that skilled immigrants contribute disproportionately to innovation and entrepreneurial activities.
A study revealed that as of 2025, nearly 46% of Fortune 500 firms were established by immigrants or their offspring.
Urging businesses to select American workers over highly skilled candidates—irrespective of origin—could impair the nation’s edge in innovation, suggested Steven Durlauf from the University of Chicago’s Stone Center.
Program Alteration Views
Some parties do not view the new H-1B framework as problematic. Ronil Hira, Howard University’s political science associate professor, voiced that modifications, including enforcing H-1B compliance, should enhance worker capabilities, pay, and conditions, bolstering the U.S. economy and its workforce.
Rutgers’ Hal Salzman articulated that the H-1B scheme frequently attracts workers willing to accept submarket wages.
He indicated salary stagnation in areas populated by guest workers, over the past two decades. Salzman doubts that companies would outsource IT roles overseas due to new H-1B restrictions, despite the potential cost savings.
"Had they intended to do so, major firms would’ve outsourced two decades ago," he noted, as some offshore IT firms are enlarging their domestic teams.
Salzman explained that about a third of the workforce must remain in the U.S. for operations to function optimally, capping potential offshoring.
Nonetheless, Zavodny argued that the hefty $100,000 cost could incentivize firms to seek talent abroad.
"That sum is substantial per employee," Zavodny remarked.



Leave a Reply