Navies Confront Renewed Challenges from Sea Drones, Future Warfare Analysis States
Armed forces are encountering a familiar predicament in a modern guise, as defense analysts have noted.
Affordable drones, designed to breach ship defenses, now enable adversaries to launch distant attacks on vessels stationed in harbors, reminiscent of a threat not prevalent since the era of World War II, according to a comprehensive new Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) report.
The latest publication from the CSIS on naval combat refers to this as a 'back to the future' juncture for maritime forces.
Mark Cancian, a senior advisor and author of the section, highlighted that the rise of uncrewed underwater vehicles (UUVs) and surface vessels (USVs) as menacing elements presents new challenges for global navies, especially when vessels remain anchored for prolonged periods, exposing them to prospective attacks.
The Strategic Vulnerability at Ports
Cancian pointed out that "a navy's significant weakness is when vessels are immobile in their docks for extended durations, offering opponents the chance to carry out strikes with careful preparation."
During the conflict in Ukraine, the Russian Black Sea Fleet repeatedly faced the harsh realities of this vulnerability, as Ukraine deployed sea drones to inflict significant damage on the Russian military presence, forcing a strategic withdrawal. Consequently, Russia has been compelled to reinforce dock defenses, enhance their vessel's defensive capabilities, and intensify routine patrols to prevent future setbacks.
Historical Context and Modern Threats
The report emphasizes that the peril of distant naval strikes on moored vessels has not been typically encountered since the events of World War II. During that period, Japanese mini-subs attacked harbors in locations such as Pearl Harbor and Ulithi Atoll, leading to ship sinkings. Similarly, German and Italian submarines targeted British ship concentrations in Egypt and near Scotland.
With the advent of modern UUVs and USVs, navy officials are discussing the need to implement protective measures at anchorages that have not been considered since WWII.
Enhancing Maritime Defense
In response to a short-range strike on the USS Cole in 2000, the United States Navy began improving harbor security for moored vessels. However, there is a necessity to add further protections to counter the evolving threat of sea drones. Cancian advises preemptive action—upgrading defenses ahead of potential attacks.
Cancian warns, however, that these defensive maneuvers must remain cost-effective and unobtrusive, ensuring that navies, particularly larger ones, can address this resurging predicament without overextending financial resources.
The Dual Nature of Emerging Technologies
Conversely, UUVs and USVs also serve as strategic assets for navies, enabling operations to infiltrate hostile zones, undertake surveillance, and engage enemy ships. These technologies present potential military applications in European and Pacific maritime environments.
"Numerous navies confront operational hurdles within adversary-protected spaces. Whereas large vessels find this challenging, uncrewed craft—being more diminutive, economical, and dispensible—prove beneficial," Cancian elucidated. NATO might contemplate targeting Russian maritime locations, while U.S. allies might explore strategies against Chinese bases. Despite the potential for attacks akin to those in Ukraine, the prevalent naval stance does not heavily favor one-way offensive drones.
Investment and Technical Challenges
Western naval forces, such as those in the UK, France, and the US, are channeling resources into developing USV and UUV technologies, particularly for operations like mine clearance and reconnaissance.
Currently, the U.S. Navy lacks programs for suicide drones. Its UUV project, Orca, is engineered for combat missions alongside reconnaissance and mine operations but has encountered substantial delays. These units are economically impractical for one-way applications since each Orca unit commands a price of roughly $110 million.
The U.S. Navy's strategic visions specify integrating hundreds of USVs and UUVs into its fleet, although current budgetary allocations do not yet reflect this projected expansion, and no formal acquisition programs are in place.
Despite the reconciliation bill setting aside approximately $5.3 billion for autonomous naval systems, there are doubts about whether navies worldwide perceive a definitive impetus for demand.
"Theoretical menaces might spur certain initiatives," Cancian observed in the CSIS analysis, "yet, an effective strike beyond the Black Sea could potentially provoke a notable response from the targeted navy, thereby alerting naval forces globally."



Leave a Reply