Increase in ‘Underwater’ Car Trade-Ins: What It Means for New Vehicle Buyers

Increase in 'Underwater' Car Trade-Ins: What It Means for New Vehicle Buyers

A growing number of car owners find themselves in a tough spot where their vehicle debt exceeds the car's market value, which creates challenges when shopping for a new vehicle.

According to Edmunds, 26.6% of car trade-ins involved negative equity in Q2 of 2025. This shows a small rise from the 26.1% reported in the prior quarter, marking the highest level seen in the past four years, as noted by Ivan Drury at Edmunds.

The peak was previously observed in the first quarter of 2021 when 31.9% of new car trades were underwater.

These underwater amounts are not trivial. On average, upside-down loans were $6,754, dipping slightly from the earlier quarter's $6,880, as Edmunds reported.

Drury describes these numbers as striking.

Experts suggest that drivers trading in a car with negative equity must either settle the balance in cash or integrate it into their new vehicle loan.

Factors Leading to Being 'Underwater'

It’s common to encounter auto loans where the borrower owes more than the car's value.

Vehicles lose value immediately after purchase, explains Brian Moody from Autotrader. Poor decisions such as long loan terms or minimal down payments can worsen this situation.

However, prolonging an auto loan can be a strategy for cost reduction, says Drury.

Loans with an 84-month duration are increasingly popular. They represented 21.6% of new car loans in Q2 2025, an increase from 19.2% in the previous quarter.

In comparison, 72-month loans slightly decreased to 36.1% during the same quarter.

While having negative equity isn't an issue while you still own the car, it becomes a problem if you need to sell or when the car is totaled.

Strategies for Purchasing a New Car with Negative Equity

Experts advise keeping your current car if possible to avoid merging the negative equity into a new loan.

If a new purchase is necessary, do thorough research before visiting a dealership. Transferring negative equity to a loan with lower interest rates can reduce overall costs.

Understanding your credit situation is vital, as knowing your score and eligibility helps secure better loan conditions.

Obtaining pre-approval from multiple lenders provides a variety of offers for comparison, which may lead to better financing or matching offers from dealers.

Should rolling over debt or long loan periods keep you underwater, ask about guaranteed asset protection (GAP) insurance, advises Moody.

GAP insurance covers the shortfall between the vehicle's worth and the outstanding loan amount in case of a total loss, according to the Insurance Information Institute.

Including GAP insurance with your coverage may add an average of $20 to your annual premium, III reports.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts