9/11 Victims' Families Allowed to Pursue Legal Action Against Saudi Arabia
In a landmark decision, a federal judge in New York has denied Saudi Arabia's request to dismiss a lawsuit filed by families of 9/11 victims. The lawsuit seeks to hold the Saudi government accountable for allegedly supporting the individuals responsible for the September 11 attacks.
This legal ruling marks a significant chapter in a protracted lawsuit that attempts to link the Saudi government with the catastrophic events orchestrated by al Qaeda. For the victims' families, navigating the complexities of this litigation has been described as a complicated and challenging endeavor.
In 2015, Saudi Arabia initially succeeded in having the case dismissed. However, that decision was later overturned by a federal appeals court. In 2016, the United States Congress passed the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act, empowering victims of acts of terror to initiate legal actions against foreign entities that may have provided assistance to the perpetrators. This legislation also granted U.S. courts the authority to hear cases involving injuries and fatalities resulting from terrorist acts on American soil.
For years, there have been allegations suggesting that officials within the Saudi government had connections to the 9/11 hijackers. Despite strong denials from Saudi Arabia, a prominent ally of the United States in the Middle East, these accusations continue to surface. Much suspicion has centered around hijackers Khalid al-Mihdhar and Nawaf al-Hazmi, who were aboard the aircraft that struck the Pentagon.
Before the attacks, al-Mihdhar and al-Hazmi resided in Los Angeles, where a Saudi named Omar al-Bayoumi allegedly assisted them in securing housing. The 9/11 Commission reported an encounter between Bayoumi and the hijackers, which was deemed coincidental.
Victims' families and their attorneys assert that Bayoumi possessed significant connections to the Saudi government and speculate he might have operated as a Saudi intelligence operative. The FBI explored whether the hijackers received aid from Fahad al-Thumairy, a Los Angeles-based Saudi diplomat and mosque imam, but the 9/11 Commission discovered no evidence supporting Thumairy’s involvement.
A '60 Minutes' episode detailed claims about Bayoumi, including video footage of him capturing images of the Capitol and indicating its position relative to the Washington Monument, hinting at a potential 'plan.' There is conjecture that the U.S. Capitol could have been the original target for Flight 93, which ultimately crashed in Pennsylvania due to passenger intervention.
Investigations long ago revealed materials in Bayoumi's residence that included drawings of planes and mathematical calculations possibly related to aircraft descent paths.
The legal representatives of victims have persistently highlighted these allegations. Despite repeated efforts by Saudi lawyers to have the claims dismissed, as recently as October 2023, the presiding judge in Manhattan has consistently rejected these requests.
Judge George Daniels, presiding over the Southern District of New York, found the plaintiffs presented credible evidence implicating Bayoumi, Thumairy, and the Saudi state in assisting the attackers. Daniels critiqued the Saudi defenses as self-contradictory or insufficiently convincing to negate the plaintiffs' assertions.
The judge noted that although intentions regarding Bayoumi remain in dispute, evidence unequivocally points to Bayoumi aiding the hijackers in housing matters and possessing a notepad containing airplane sketches and numerical notes at his residence.
Saudi advocates characterized Bayoumi's involvement with the hijackers as mere circumstance and insisted his assistance was a matter of politeness. They argued that the airplane sketch was unrelated to the attacks and pertained to a school project for Bayoumi's son.
Judge Daniels dismissed these defenses as speculative and without substantive foundation, highlighting contradictions and a lack of compelling justification.
Sean P. Carter, representing the plaintiffs, expressed satisfaction with the court's meticulous decision and anticipation for the case to advance toward trial.
The legal team at Kreindler & Kreindler LLP, also representing the victims’ families, emphasized that the ruling sustains the pursuit of truth and justice, facilitating an exhaustive trial examination of critical issues.
The Justice Department and the Saudi Embassy did not offer immediate reactions to inquiries for private commentary.



Leave a Reply