Experiencing a Luxurious $97 Lobster Salad in Montauk: Pricey Cuisine, Priceless Views
Imagine cruising along a sun-drenched Long Island stretch, bypassing the Hamptons and reaching Montauk—often termed 'The End.'
Over time, Montauk has evolved from a modest surf town into a bustling hub for socialites and financial moguls. Despite modern developments, some iconic spots remain unchanged by time.
Enter Duryea's Lobster Deck, a middle ground between revered tradition and modern flair. The Duryea family acquired a modest bay-side fish market in Montauk during the 1920s. With time, it transformed into a landmark, albeit not a conventional restaurant due to local rules. Instead, it was famously referred to as a 'picnic shack.'
In 2014, Perry Duryea III sold this historic establishment to billionaire Mark Rowan for $6.3 million. Today, picnic tables have been replaced with elegant seating and high-end seafood offerings.
In August, on a sunny Monday, I ventured to experience the updated Duryea's.
Duryea's: A Pillar of Montauk's History
Founded in the 1920s as a humble fish market, Duryea's was shaped into its current form in 1948 by Perry Duryea Jr. The venue has expanded beyond a singular market to include a duo of dining establishments and international beach clubs.
An Unexpected Crowd on a Quiet Monday
I misjudged the allure of Duryea’s on a Monday. By noon, it was bustling with visitors.
A Refreshingly Open-Air Experience
With no traditional indoor seating, the deck is the favored location. Less than an hour post-opening, the setting was lively and ready for visitors arriving by boat.
Charming Minimalist Décor
With light wood and white tables, the setting makes for a picturesque backdrop.
Nostalgic with a Hint of Humor
Jokingly, a sign stated, 'we're all celebrities here.'
Choose and Order: A Simplified Dining Approach
Customers mark their selections on the menu before bringing them to the counter—a nod to the laid-back beachside roots of the venue.
A Menu Not for the Faint-Hearted
At Duryea's, seafood delights can hefty a price tag. With $345 seafood towers and $45 lobster rolls, elegance meets expense.
Our order: the renowned $97 lobster Cobb salad, a lobster roll, crispy fries, and seasonal beverages.
Exploring Duryea's Offerings
The venue extends beyond dining with merchandise and a curated boutique.
A glance into their cooler reveals fresh seafood, ready for preparation.
Tasting the Notorious Lobster Cobb Salad
The generous portion size of the salad can comfortably feed multiple diners, with generous chunks of lobster and a range of toppings.
A Hefty Price Tag, Not Entirely Justified
Despite the abundance of lobster morsels, beyond the top layer lay mainly lettuce. The dressing didn't win me over either.
Opting for the lobster roll is an economical choice while still offering substantial lobster portions paired with house-made chips.
Fries that Steal the Show
Perfectly crispy, these fries are a standout. Their shoestring cut appeals to a broad audience.
Paying for the Enviable Atmosphere
The serene bayside location combined with a chilled drink signify the true value at Duryea's.
Being conscious of budget might deter some from this venue, yet for those with means, it remains a suggested stop.
While alternatives may offer affordable fare, few match the scenic charm of Duryea's. Returning for more lobster rolls and the view seems a wise decision.



Leave a Reply