Gen Z's New Masculine Persona: Who to Watch Out For
Is the 'performative male' something to be cautious about?
In bustling cities, it's not uncommon to witness a scene resembling a quirky fashion parade: young men flaunting tote bags, displaying feminist books, and brandishing their latest vinyl album purchases.
Your guess isn't far off. Over recent weeks, young people across the nation—and even abroad—have been organizing events highlighting the most convincing 'performative male,' a trend rapidly gaining traction on TikTok.
The term might be deceptive. A 'performative male' doesn't channel the classic traits of a 'gym enthusiast.' Instead, he cultivates an alternative, intellectual, and ‘soft’ vibe, as Gen Z describes it, often to appeal to progressive women. This persona may engage with matcha, devour works by bell hooks, enjoy female singer-songwriters, and carry emergency feminine products. Picture Jacob Elordi lugging around several books, or Paul Mescal fangirling over Mitski.
Largely seen as harmless fun, it humorously tips the hat at guys who genuinely appreciate matcha and Mitski. It mirrors last year's celebrity lookalike contests, which highlighted people's love for quirky costumes and communal spaces. According to Malik Marcus Jernigan, the winner of Seattle's 'performative male' contest, most participants—himself included—naturally fit the bill.
"My pal nudged me to join, saying I had a solid shot at winning. So, I went for it to make them proud," shares Jernigan, a 24-year-old musician. "For the most part, it's about 'performative males' playfully mocking themselves or women teasing them online—it's all in good jest."
Yet, there's a clouded perspective: perhaps these men aren't as they appear, and their tastes and actions might disguise a façade. This adds them to a roster of dubious male archetypes, akin to the duplicitous "wife guy" or the deceitful "male manipulator."
What led these traits to become suspect? Should you fret over a man who's into Clairo? Is appearing ‘performative’ such a negative when identity itself can be a performance?
From 'hipsters' to 'soft boys,' down to the less flattering 'cuckboi,' the online world has long scrutinized these men who defy traditional masculinity through style or habits.
Today's digital age, notably through TikTok, has introduced a broader audience to men who freely challenge gender norms. Jordan Foster, a sociology associate professor at MacEwan University, notes that the platform has provided typical men with unparalleled public exposure, significantly altering their self-presentation and gender expression.
Yet, even as acceptance grows for this man type, it hasn’t eased our confusion. They are frequently tagged as emotionally aware and without issues, supporting progressive, even feminist views. Is it all genuine, though?
The internet seems locked in a cycle: praising these men, then doubting their sincerity when they gain fame. Harry Styles became a prime example—once celebrated for sporting feminine attire and sharing dances with men, he later faced accusations of 'queer-baiting,' where straight, cis men exploit queer aesthetics for gain.
Foster indicates that questioning men adopting these aesthetics often hinges on privilege. "The critique centers on men enjoying social and symbolic benefits from embracing these feminized or queer styles without facing the challenges endured by queer or marginalized communities," he explains.
In his exploration of 'radical' masculinities on TikTok, Foster observed that men comfortable with dresses or matcha consumption often possess 'masculine capital'—they're typically cisgender, white, good-looking, and socio-economically privileged—making them more secure in exploring these styles. He adds that 'softboy' markers frequently amplify their conventional appeal. For instance, think of Styles donning a pink vest that shows off his abs, or actor Jeremy Allen White wearing shorts flaunting his muscular thighs.
It's not just that these signs appear calculated or trivial; they can be deceptive. The MeToo era highlighted that even 'nice guys' could manipulate or abuse, hiding behind a façade of wokeness. The archetype of the duplicitous man who goes to therapy yet mistreats his partner is now meme fodder, and portrayals of faux-enlightened men permeate popular culture.
In what some interpret as attempts to polish their public image post-controversy, celebrities like Brad Pitt, after abuse allegations from Angelina Jolie, have embraced more fluid gender expressions. Jonathan Majors, before his domestic-violence charges, donned pink in a viral shoot, discoursing on masculinity as 'kind' and 'gentle.' Were these gestures to deflect negative PR? It's uncertain, but such actions certainly influence the narrative.
The Trust Gap in Dating
Nonetheless, these snap judgments can hinder young adults' social interactions. According to Playboy editor Magdalene J. Taylor, the 'performative male' phenomenon echoes the escalating mistrust in modern dating: we doubt everyone’s good intentions.
This skepticism manifests in the barrage of dating criteria and unspoken protocols shared on TikTok and whisper apps prioritizing gossip over safety. It's as if many have forgotten the fundamentals of discerning wisely in dating.
Focusing on Genuine Traits
Taylor suggests that out of genuine red flags, a man's choice in clothing or literary preferences shouldn’t be major concerns. The appeal to a partner isn't automatically deceitful.
"Certainly, misleading people for sexual gain is wrong and potentially harmful, but reading a book you think appeals to women isn’t deceitful," Taylor comments. "It’s a longstanding, reasonable social practice of bridging gaps with the opposite gender."
Taylor opines that the humor both genders bring to the 'performative male' trend indicates a slow departure from scrutinizing every feminine-coded interest in men. Many men just happen to appreciate the same things at the moment; if progressive women like those, it’s just coincidence.
"It’s not directly opposing 'wokeness' but perhaps realizing that some of its narratives on straight dating added unnecessary restrictions," Taylor remarks. "We're returning to acknowledging personal desires and natural behaviors."



Leave a Reply