The Magic of Using ETFs to Avoid Capital Gains Taxes
Over the years, many investors have seen substantial gains within taxable accounts. These gains could result in considerable tax obligations when realized.
For affluent individuals in the U.S., this tax obligation can be substantial, with capital gains taxes hitting up to 20%, and an additional 3.8% depending on one's income tier.
A potential solution called a 351 exchange enables these investors to convert valuable assets into new ETF shares, letting them push capital gain taxes into the future until those shares are sold.
For some, this strategy is nearly miraculous, as noted by David Haas, a financial advisor and president of Cereus Financial in New Jersey.
Understanding the ETF Strategy
An appealing feature of ETFs is that managers can accept assets before making them publicly available and adjust holdings over time.
Despite a rise in 351 exchanges involving ETFs recently, there remain limited public options, according to industry experts.
Haas has utilized the 351 exchange approach with various clients, yet acknowledges potential drawbacks. Here's what you need to know:
Navigating 351 Conversions to ETFs
Many high-income individuals maintain part of their wealth in personalized investment accounts known as Separately Managed Accounts (SMAs), which are actively managed and taxable.
A perk of SMAs is the practice of offsetting profits using losses, known as tax-loss harvesting, but this becomes less feasible as investments grow, per Daniel Sotiroff from Morningstar.
Eventually, there aren't enough losses to exploit, complicating the alteration of investments without incurring capital gains taxes.
Converting assets to ETFs via 351 exchanges might address these issues for some investors.
Large financial entities managing client SMAs can form private ETFs through 351 conversions; smaller firms or SMAs now have access to foundational ETFs.
The future may see even more participation, although the current minimum investment remains steep, such as a $1 million baseline advised for individual participation.
Diversification is Key in 351 Exchanges
Avoiding capital gains taxes on embedded profits through a 351 exchange requires adherence to firm guidelines.
Ben Henry-Moreland from Kitces.com advises that merely transferring a single stock doesn't qualify for deferred tax benefits.
Transfer laws are stringent and assets must be deemed "diversified" to qualify.
Certain assets—like some mutual funds or less traditional assets such as private equity or cryptocurrencies—may not be eligible, as emphasized by Henry-Moreland.
Potential Limitations of 351 Conversions
Before proceeding with a 351 conversion, evaluate its place within your financial strategy. Swapping assets for ETF shares might shift your investment balance.
Charles Sachs from Imperio Wealth points out that this approach might restrict investor options.
"It's a valid strategy, but once in, you’re committed," Sachs notes.
Although funds can potentially be moved through another 351 conversion, few companies offer this service, and selling might incur capital gains.
"It's critically important to be pleased with your ETF choice," Haas advises.



Leave a Reply