Choosing the Ideal Breast Pump

Selecting the right breast pump is a significant decision for breastfeeding parents. Whether you plan on pumping for a few months or longer, a reliable pump can make the process more manageable.

Nowadays, parents can choose from a wide range of options, from pricy wearables that fit within your bra, to lightweight pumps you can wear around your neck. But which ones offer the best efficiency? Our team at WIRED, including several mothers who have personally tested these pumps, shares insights into what worked best.

Top Picks for Portable Pumps

Genie Advanced Portable Pump

When considering 'portable pumps,' a certain image comes to mind: a compact yet strong motor that easily fits in any bag. This model can work as both a single or double electric pump and features customized session recording. The comfortable flanges and bottle combo, despite being non-dishwasher safe, make it an excellent choice for comfort during use.

This closed system is adaptable with other shield kits, though our tests focused on the proprietary Liquid Kit by Pumpables. It provides a comfortable, although slightly cumbersome, cleaning experience that pays off in performance.

Leading Wearable Pump

Willow Go Wearable Pump

A more affordable alternative in the wearable category, the Willow Go remains competitive with high-end models like the Elvie, providing similar features with a seamless experience. It's compatible with most bras, increasing its versatility.

This device includes reusable cups that allow easy monitoring during pumping, with parts that can go in the dishwasher. It has a dedicated app for operation instructions and a built-in timer, although it is compatible solely with its own components.

Economical Pumping Solutions

Imani i2 by Legendairy Milk

For those on a tight budget, this wearable pump is the preferred option. While it lacks modern app functionalities and a screen, it delivers excellent performance for its price. A simple structure with essential pumping modes makes it accessible and practical.

Advanced Wearable Pump for Upgrade

Willow 3.0

This premium pump boasts features such as breast suction and precise ounce tracking. Despite the high cost, it's a worthwhile investment for those seeking efficiency and comfort.

The functionality allows milk collection in sealed bags or reusable containers, requiring specific flange sizes chosen at purchase for optimal performance.

Portable with Wearable Cups

Elvie Stride 2

A true hands-free experience, this pump allows multitasking with comfort. Its discreet design and external battery pack enhance mobility, though extra milk storage is often necessary.

Despite needing manual adjustments due to the app's basic features, its capability to transform pumping into a routine activity makes it appealing.

Traditional Double Electric Pump

Spectra S1

Renowned for its reliability, this double electric pump is user-friendly, with adjustable settings and a night light for convenient nighttime use.

Although not the most compact, its performance and durability earn it a top spot among breastfeeding essentials.

Simplest Cleaning Experience

Medela Freestyle

Designed with ease in mind, each cup has minimalistic parts, making it quick to clean and reassemble. Care must be taken to avoid spills, but overall, it offers a streamlined pumping session.

Haakaa Manual Pump

A cost-effective manual option for capturing milk effortlessly, this simple device is ideal for brief relief and not extensive pumping sessions.

Occasionally indispensable, it’s suited for managing overflow during specific situations rather than continuous use.