Concerns Arise Over Trump's Tax Proposal on Tips
A provision named ‘no tax on tips’ in President Donald Trump's newly passed legislation is attracting attention. This concept had the support of both major political parties during the 2024 elections. Although the law is active, many questions linger about its application and eligibility.
Contrary to what the name suggests, 'no tax on tips' doesn't entirely exempt tips from taxes. They are still liable for payroll and state taxes. The essence of this provision lies in a deduction. It's applicable from the year 2025 until the end of 2028 and begins to reduce when an individual's adjusted gross income surpasses $150,000.
The IRS is currently slated to release more information on which jobs will fall under this deduction by early October.
Experts like Larry Gray, a certified public accountant from Missouri and an IRS liaison for the National Association of Tax Professionals, describe the current guidance as akin to peering into a crystal ball.
In 2023, approximately four million Americans worked in jobs that typically earn tips, according to Yale University's The Budget Lab.
However, only a fraction of workers will qualify, including performers and creatives, such as actors and musicians. Certain groups, as specified by the legislation, are excluded from enjoying these benefits.
Understanding 'Qualified Tips'
The term 'qualified tips' refers to cash tips an employee receives. This could be tips handed directly in cash or added onto a credit card payment, as well as amounts shared via a tip pooling system.
The law states that a tip must stem from a voluntary agreement by the customer, complicating the inclusion of other gratuity types, like obligatory service fees.
Alex Muresianu, who is a seasoned policy analyst at the Tax Foundation, emphasized, "It must be a purely voluntary act."
This means compulsory add-ons, such as a mandatory service fee for large dining groups, may not be considered voluntary.
As Ben Henry-Moreland, a certified financial analyst associated with Kitces.com, observed, the straightforward language of the law suggests that mandatory fees don’t appear to be voluntary.
Reporting Tips Accurately
To benefit from the tax deduction, it’s crucial for tips to be officially recorded, as noted by Melanie Lauridsen, vice president of tax policy at AICPA.
Employers are required to document an employee's tips on forms such as W-2s or 1099s, ensuring a copy goes to both the employee and the IRS.
The adjustment to income reporting thresholds under Trump's law could create complexities for workers relying primarily on tips if these forms aren't provided.
For instance, fiscal platforms like Venmo or gig services have certain income thresholds. By 2025, the threshold for issuing a 1099-K will be reset to $20,000 and 200 transactions, a change from former limits.
From 2026 onward, any contract earnings reported through a 1099-NEC will need to meet a new $2,000 threshold, up from the previous $600.
A prevalent issue remains whether employees truthfully report all cash tips to their employers and tax authorities.
Ben Henry-Moreland highlights a major issue with the 'no tax on tips' policy: a significant volume of these earnings aren’t reported at all.



Leave a Reply