Pandemic Reflections Through ‘Eddington’: A Missed Mark

Pandemic Reflections Through 'Eddington': A Missed Mark

While 'Eddington' successfully captures the essence and absurdities of 2020, it fails to offer deeper insights.

A24, a distributor noted for its distinguished arthouse films, initially thrived with high-concept horror movies like Ari Aster's 'Hereditary' and 'Midsommar'. As the years have passed, the ambitions of both A24 and Aster have grown to encompass narratives that transcend their original genres. However, the results lately have varied significantly.

Ari Aster's recent work, 'Eddington', is stylistically akin to his previous effort, 'Beau Is Afraid', with Joaquin Phoenix reprising a lead role. This time, the narrative shifts focus from past existential themes to contemporary issues of political correctness and conspiracy thinking, all set against the backdrop of the early COVID-19 pandemic. Its tagline, “Hindsight is 2020,” is cleverly ironic for a film that is both witty and superficially entertaining.

In a made-up New Mexican town, Sheriff Joe Cross, played by Phoenix, is disgruntled with the state's COVID-19 measures. Although not a direct representation of any political ideology, he regards mask-wearing as a personal affront due to his asthma. While Eddington has yet to face the direct impact of the virus, the unease sparked by mask mandates, grocery shortages, and online conspiracy theories overshadows the town as much as the virus itself. Dissatisfied with the current state of affairs, Cross declares his candidacy for mayor via a live broadcast.

Intended as a metaphor for America's flaws, Aster's analysis feels overly generalized, though the film excels in its details. Eddington is populated by eccentric individuals, brought to life by a notable cast. Pedro Pascal portrays Ted Garcia, the incumbent mayor engrossed in selling the town's future for a large AI facility. Emma Stone takes on the role of Cross’ wife Louise, who makes unsettling dolls as a hobby, while Deirdre O’Connell plays her mother Dawn, a conspiracy theory enthusiast swayed by YouTube misinformation. Austin Butler features as Vernon, a tattooed cult leader reminiscent of a Hillsong pastor. Episode after episode, watching recognizable actors embrace bizarre roles recalls a mix of Wes Anderson’s stylistic charm and Yorgos Lanthimos’ dark wit. The charm lies in watching them interact and riff off each other, possibly having enjoyed the filming process.

The movie also touches on themes of social justice by addressing Black Lives Matter protests, although with an awkward lens. The leader of Eddington’s movement is a white teenager (Amélie Hoeferle) persistently offering naïve advice to her Black ex, a police officer named Michael (Micheal Ward), about activism. Seeing two other teens join protests mainly because they’re attracted to her highlights, once again, Aster’s humor in exposing the contradictions in activist rhetoric.

Initially, 'Eddington' avoids heavy-handedness, presenting political and social themes with humor and neutrality. Despite its somewhat predictable setup regarding political stereotypes, the humor manages to resonate. Aster suggests that regardless of political orientation, people are equally swayed by smartphone notifications and the algorithms of social media. Even though the theme may seem evident, Aster handles it with credible finesse.

This coherence falls apart in the last act, revealing Aster’s possible difficulty with conclusions. While the tonal shift to absurdity might suit a dark comedy, it detracts from a narrative that started on a relatable note. Without giving spoilers, the story veers into a chaotic plotline as Joe Cross’ actions become abruptly drastic and bewildering, failing to align with the film’s prior sensibilities.

Reflecting on the pandemic, it's clear that a few years' distance might still be insufficient to fully comprehend its impact on society or individuals. Nonetheless, the film's proposition that the pandemic merely fractured our mental states seems insufficient for sustaining a compelling story. Despite Joaquin Phoenix's charismatic portrayal, Joe Cross' drastic character change feels misplaced and poorly developed.

Nevertheless, 'Eddington' leaves lasting impressions. A keen eye for amusing and deliberate details, like the police station with desktops adorned in anime stickers, or a fleeting glimpse of a TikTok clip featuring a jubilant dance over 'wokeness', enrich the viewing experience. Aster showcases a meticulous attention to craft, seen in his careful set designs and authentic pandemic depictions. It’s unfortunate this same precision didn’t extend to the narrative depth.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts