Trump’s Unprecedented Power Grab

Trump's Unprecedented Power Grab

A revelation has surfaced just ahead of the Fourth of July, showing that President Donald Trump discreetly assumed a power deemed so hazardous even King George couldn't wield it.

Detailed in a set of identical letters from Attorney General Pam Bondi to ten major tech firms on April 5, Trump directed these companies to disregard Congress’s law outlawing TikTok in the United States. The messages emerged following a Freedom of Information request and are filled with feeble justifications for why these companies could continue to allow TikTok on their platforms despite explicit legal prohibitions.

When combined, the claims in these letters announce an audacious assertion of power: the president is allegedly able to exclude particular companies from legal constraints if he considers such laws to impede his foreign policy objectives.

The Concept of Dispensing Power

This idea of 'dispensing power' was once a privilege of English monarchs, enabling them to declare laws inapplicable to their allies—extending beyond international issues. These dispensations acted like anticipatory pardons, allowing selected individuals to overlook specific laws without repercussions.

Due to its extensive and undemocratic nature, this power was explicitly eliminated by the 1689 English Bill of Rights. In 1838, the US Supreme Court repudiated the notion that the president possessed a dispensing power, with scholars widely agreeing with this ruling today.

Attorney General's Argument

The short, six-paragraph Bondi letters don’t openly declare a dispensing power but jumble several legal points without cohesively linking them into a clear stance. Law professor Alan Rozenshtein, who has been monitoring the TikTok case, expressed his frustration over the letters' lack of legal clarity.

The underlying argument seems to assert that Constitution’s Article II gives the president autonomous authority to evaluate whether legislation would interfere with his duties related to national security and international affairs.

According to Bondi, if Trump assesses that a law might obstruct his foreign affairs conduct, he could securely assure companies or individuals that the government will not press charges should they breach that law.

Historical Precedents and Legal Interpretations

While it’s recognized that Article II powers can be unduly limited by legislation—evident in past Supreme Court decisions affected by these issues—most legislative restrictions on presidential foreign policy are constitutional.

It’s a well-held belief that presidents have some flexibility in the execution of laws due to limited enforcement resources. However, the TikTok scenario diverges significantly as it wasn’t about redistributing resources but was instead about providing carte blanche to tech companies to ignore a law they were already obeying.

Potential Dangers of the Dispensing Power

A comparable concept to understand this power grab is the presidential pardon, which, while abusable, typically pertains to criminal law and doesn’t allow pardoning of civil infractions.

Legal expert Jack Goldsmith notes that Bondi’s letters suggest the capacity to preemptively pardon civil violations, which could let the president authorize broadly illegal activities under foreign policy excuses.

Although currently used only to bypass the TikTok ban, this rationale could become a template for future executive overreach.

Conclusion: A Broader Threat

The ramifications of this potential abuse of power extend beyond the immediate tech ban controversy and signal a troubling move towards greater executive authority. Without a strong legal challenge, it lays the groundwork for further unconstitutional expansions of power under the guise of foreign policy management.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts