Six Common Pitfalls in Wedding Menu Selection, According to an Expert Caterer
Crafting the ideal wedding meal can be fraught with errors that may end up affecting the guests' experience.
Since catering often represents a significant portion of the wedding budget, a clear dialogue with your caterer is essential to ensure your expectations are met.
Based on The Knot's 2025 Real Weddings Study, catering averages around $80 per guest. Prices can differ depending on the locale and the coordinator you select.
Many couples are eager to invest in premium wedding food, with 58% reportedly prioritizing dining and beverage aspects of their plans. This statistic originates from a study of 17,000 couples in the U.S. who tied the knot in 2024.
Recently, Business Insider engaged in a discussion with Lexi Ritsch, a co-founder of the event planning firm Hamptons Aristocrat, based in New York and Florida, about the most frequent errors couples encounter when deciding on their wedding catering.
Here are the six most common blunders she notices among couples.
Mistake 1: Opting for Out-of-Season or Non-Local Ingredients
Among the most noticeable missteps, Ritsch points out is the choice to use ingredients that are not in season or locally sourced.
"If someone insists on serving Brussels sprouts in the middle of summer, my immediate reaction is one of disbelief," she humorously remarked.
She advises couples to select seasonal and locally-sourced produce instead.
"A tomato that's traveled half the world is incomparable to one freshly picked from the vine," she emphasizes.
Mistake 2: Sticking to Basic Salad Options
Ritsch expresses her dislike for the trend of starting dinner with a mundane salad.
"Could we move beyond basic salads? Alternatively, if a salad is essential, why not create a visually appealing dish with unique ingredients such as whipped ricotta and specialty croutons entangled with seasonal greens and a flavorful dressing?" she advises.
Ritsch dislikes ordinary or generic 'preset' salads that lack creativity.
Mistake 3: The Overuse of Family-Style Buffets
"There's a shift away from traditional family-style buffets towards more elegant dining options reminiscent of upscale dining experiences," states Ritsch.
Clients are increasingly favoring restaurant-style service which allows for more refined and personalized meal presentations.
Mistake 4: Spending Excessively on the Wedding Cake
One tradition Ritsch sees fading is the grandiose wedding cake.
"Previously, cakes were as prominent as the celebrations themselves, often costing thousands," she observes. "Nowadays, budget-conscious couples are scaling back, focusing instead on interactive and fun dessert alternatives like ice cream bars or nostalgic family desserts."
Mistake 5: Limiting Choices to Conventional 'Wedding Foods'
Despite their popularity, she feels the traditional trifecta of chicken, fish, or steak often lacks imagination and uniqueness.
"Big events can sometimes tempt caterers to cut corners, offering uninspired pairings. Instead of default options, each dish should be thoughtfully created and tailored," Ritsch explains.
Mistake 6: Overlooking Customization with the Caterer
One critical warning sign in selecting a caterer is the offering of preset menus with minimal options for personalization.
"If a caterer presents limited selections that suggest an inflexible approach, be cautious," she warns.
Ritsch advises choosing a caterer known for their creativity and adaptability rather than one-size-fits-all solutions.
She asserts that every wedding menu should be distinct and representative of personal tastes and dietary needs.



Leave a Reply