Comparing Barbecue Burgers From Three Fast-Food Giants

Comparing Barbecue Burgers From Three Fast-Food Giants

When it comes to barbecue burgers, the combination of tangy, smoky sauce with crunchy fried onions and tart pickles is unbeatable.

For many, barbecue sauce symbolizes summer, appearing everywhere from backyard cookouts to fast-food drive-ins. But when identifying which fast-food burger provides the best value and flavor, opinions can diverge.

Starting With the Least Favorite: Smashburger

Smashburger, now present in 34 states from its Colorado roots, serves up a BBQ Bacon Smashburger for $10.86, pre-tax. Among the trio tried, this was the most budget-friendly.

This burger is layered with cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon, crispy fried onions, and barbecue sauce. Although it includes crunchy onion pieces and discernible sauce, the patty felt a bit dry to me.

Downsides: Overdone Patty and Onion Issues

The fried onions absorbed a lot of the moisture, resulting in a dry experience.

Cooked beyond my preference, the well-done patty didn’t hit the mark for me, though cooking styles vary by taste. Additionally, the cheese lacked melting, failing to mitigate the burger's dryness. However, the bacon stood out with its perfect cooking and rich smokiness.

In the Middle: Burger King's Effort

Choosing a BBQ Bacon Whopper Jr. with cheese cost me $11.09, which is a bit steep for a smaller burger.

Within a sesame seed bun, it’s topped traditionally — lettuce, tomato, onion, barbecue sauce, mayonnaise, pickles, and crispy bacon strips.

The combination of condiments, cheese, and juicy tomato contributed moisture without making it soggy.

Although the bacon was crisp, it lacked the robust flavor of the bacon from the other contenders. It presented itself as a solid cheeseburger yet didn't loudly communicate a barbecue flourish as expected. Though tasty and classically styled, it missed a distinctive barbecue touch.

Top Choice: Shake Shack's BBQ Burger

Shake Shack, available in 30 states and DC, offers barbecue variations like the Smoky Classic BBQ burger and the Carolina BBQ with fried pickles. Opting for the classic with fried onions and bacon set me back $13.29, the priciest among the three.

This burger was a visual delight, expertly layered with ample toppings and doused in a savory barbecue sauce.

The sauce seamlessly enveloped the soft bun and toppings. I noted thick pickle slices and a generous portion of crispy onions and bacon crowning the patty.

The cheese melded seamlessly over the crisply cooked patty, while the soft bun secured everything.

Conclusion: A Restaurant-Caliber Burger

While the burger was crisp, it was still cooked perfectly medium, and the onions delivered a delightful crunch without being dry, unlike the Smashburger counterpart. These onions were reminiscent of onion rings—crunchy and flavorful.

With refreshing pickles accentuating the flavors, this was the sole burger where the barbecue sauce's smokiness was notably detectable, complemented by the cheese, beef, and bacon. Despite its high cost, it delivered superb quality worth every cent.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts