The Steep Cost of Car Ownership for Californians
Franchescoli Andrade faces a daily challenge: his commute to work without a car requires a combination of cycling, train rides, and buses.
Each leg of his 20-mile commute from South Los Angeles to the San Fernando Valley takes him an hour and a half one way.
"It takes about 30 minutes just to navigate downtown and reach the train station. Another half-hour on the train before a final bus ride completes my trip to work," Andrade explained. "I make this effort daily to support my family."
Andrade's situation was less complicated when he owned a vehicle. However, after an accident, repairing the car was too expensive, especially as he is the only income earner in his family.
"Every paycheck feels like a struggle," he confessed.
To economize on childcare, Andrade's spouse remains home to look after their young son. "It's deeply troubling," he shared. "I often feel inadequate, like I’m not contributing enough."
A Widespread Financial Dilemma
The difficulties experienced by Andrade are reflective of the broader issues faced by many in California. According to a United Way report, 35% of households in the state, approximately 3.8 million, struggle to meet basic living expenses such as housing, food, and fuel.
Pete Manzo, CEO of United Way, commented on these findings.
"It's a crisis that's persistent," Manzo told CBS News. "It's akin to having a fever that won't break—a situation where countless families work tirelessly but can't secure a comfortable standard of living."
The Burden of Transportation Costs
A significant hurdle is the cost of owning a car. According to AAA, the expenses associated with a new vehicle—encompassing payments, insurance, upkeep, and gas—exceed $12,000 annually for a typical American family.
"This essentially means that families must budget around $1,000 a month or more just for commuting to work and school," Manzo highlighted. "And it's not cheap." While California often faces higher costs, this pattern is mirrored across the country, where inflation continues to drive up expenses for transportation, along with housing and childcare, as noted in United Way's analyses.
While relocating to a cheaper area might seem viable for some, Manzo pointed out its impracticality for many.
"For certain families, moving might indeed offer some relief," Manzo observed. "Nonetheless, abandoning longstanding familial and community connections for lower expenses isn't a feasible option for everyone… Suggesting such a move for the masses lacks sensibility."
Planning for the Future
For now, Andrade is diligently saving to purchase another vehicle. "My family encourages me with 'hang in there, you can do this,'" he shared.
Elise Preston, who compiled this report, is a dedicated CBS News correspondent based in Los Angeles, contributing to multiple CBS news platforms.



Leave a Reply