A Revival of Tariff Engineering: How Companies Strategize to Reduce Duty Costs

A Revival of Tariff Engineering: How Companies Strategize to Reduce Duty Costs

Does it matter to you if your coat is classified as a windbreaker instead of a raincoat, or if your shoes are labeled as slippers? For businesses, these distinctions are crucial as they can significantly lower the amount they have to pay in tariffs.

In response to the trade tariffs imposed by former President Donald Trump, manufacturers are swiftly re-evaluating how they categorize their products, utilizing a method known as 'tariff engineering' to diminish duties, according to expertise from customs attorneys, supply chain analysts, and shipping specialists.

Tariff engineering, a technique existing long before Trump's time, involves modifying an item’s materials or dimensions to ensure its classification into a more advantageous tariff category, as noted by legal professionals.

While numerous tariffs established in Trump’s administration were comprehensive, certain gaps in the regulations have allowed companies opportunities to benefit through tariff engineering, as noted by trade attorneys.

Since the introduction of widespread reciprocal tariffs by Trump in April, several foreign producers have adapted by integrating steel and aluminum into final products, qualifying for a lower duty rate, shared David Forgue, of the law firm Barnes, Richardson & Colburn in Chicago.

However, the circumstances shifted significantly in June as tariffs on all steel and aluminum products and derivatives were raised to 50%, exempting those from the U.K. This change prompted companies to again separate these materials, Forgue elaborated.

According to John Foote, a customs attorney at Kelley Drye & Warren, there is nothing unlawful about making deliberate design decisions to achieve different tariff classifications and reduce duty costs. Tariff engineering is a legitimate approach to minimize duty liabilities.

Ingenious Approaches

Foote recounted a recent interaction where a classic festive lapel pin, equipped with cubic zirconia, was reclassified as jewelry—thereby avoiding a 14% tariff, a relatively simple manufacturing modification.

The concept of tariff engineering dates back to 1882 when an importer avoided higher duties on lighter-colored sugar by coating it with molasses. The Supreme Court upheld this practice as legal as long as transactions were transparent and honest.

Several household names engage in strategic product modifications to leverage tariff classifications. For example, Columbia Sportswear doesn’t hide its use of tariff engineering, incorporating small zippered pockets in women's shirts to avoid higher duties.

Similarly, a footwear company altered its sneaker soles to be identified as slippers, thereby reducing tariffs. Snuggie, the blanket with sleeves, effectively filed a lawsuit to be categorized as a blanket, not clothing, cutting its tariff expenses in half.

Andrew Wilson from Supplino Inc. observes that consumer goods and apparel sectors can implement tariff engineering more readily, whereas highly-regulated sectors face significant validation processes.

In sectors like automotive and aerospace, even minor design changes require extensive validation and cooperation across departments, all to comply with detailed regulations.

Complex Rules and Interpretations

Businesses walk a fine line between redesigning products to lower tariffs and misreporting classifications. Ford’s strategy of importing vans as passenger vehicles before removing seats to sell them as cargo vans led to allegations of misclassification by the U.S. Justice Department.

The essential nature of a product must remain unchanged during importation; otherwise, Customs might see modifications as deceitful, warned Forgue.

U.S. Customs and Border Control offers a program allowing businesses to acquire official rulings on product classifications before imports, confirmed Adam Lees from Harris Sliwoski.

Even small duty savings can accumulate into significant financial benefits for businesses with high shipping volumes, Lees noted.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts