Conviction in Sycamore Gap Tree Destruction Case

In 2023, a landmark case concluded with two men being found guilty for the destruction of the renowned Sycamore Gap tree in northern England.

Daniel Graham and Adam Carruthers stood trial at Newcastle Crown Court, where the jury returned a guilty verdict, charging both with causing criminal damage to the historic tree and its consequential impact on Hadrian’s Wall.

After spending nearly four hours considering their decision on Thursday, jurors reached a consensus within half an hour the following morning, confirming the culpability of the accused.

Testimonies and Evidence

Once partners in camaraderie, Graham and Carruthers each denied their involvement in the incident under oath. Graham, in particular, deflected responsibility onto Carruthers during his testimony.

Despite their denials, the prosecution presented compelling evidence including footage discovered on Graham's mobile device showing the tree being felled. Moreover, it was revealed that his vehicle, a Range Rover, was traced to the scene of the crime on the September night when this act occurred.

Crucially, messages exhibited during the trial revealed the men’s exchanges the following morning, where they appeared to boast about the event, amidst widespread media coverage.

Valuation and Impact

The eradicated tree, an icon revered by both locals and tourists alike, was estimated to hold a value exceeding £620,000 (approaching $830,000). Additionally, the harm inflicted upon the ancient wall was assessed at over £1,100 (near $1,500).