Chicago Celebrates Its Native Son: Pope Leo XIV

CHICAGO — Sherry Stone was astonished to discover that her childhood companion, Robert Prevost, had ascended to the distinguished role of the 267th pope on Thursday. In a move few can replicate, she sent him a congratulatory email.

"I suggested that our upcoming grade school reunion should happen at the Vatican," Stone humorously remarked.

The elevation of Barack Obama, a former Hyde Park resident, to the presidency in 2009 energized Chicago for an extended period. Similarly, the city rejoiced at the news of Robert Prevost becoming the first American pope, Pope Leo XIV. Online, memes spread rapidly, depicting the new pope wearing emblems of Chicago culture—a Cubs hat, a hot dog, and even wielding a bottle of Malort, a local liqueur. In a celebratory gesture, the Cubs' iconic marquee at Wrigley Field gleefully announced, "Hey Chicago, He's a Cubs Fan!" Meanwhile, Bennison's Bakery in Evanston crafted a sugar cookie adorned with Prevost's image, claiming it was "as divine as the occasion."

The Governor of Illinois, JB Pritzker, described the pope’s election as a "monumental milestone." He stated, "Pope Leo XIV heralds a hopeful era of compassion, cohesion, and serenity."

Chicago Mayor Brandon Johnson echoed these sentiments with a more casual message on social media, quipping, "Chicago produces greatness, and now, even the pope! Congratulations to Pope Leo XIV! We eagerly await your return home."

Leo, who spent years in northern Peru gaining experience as a bishop and citizen, has deep roots in Chicago's southwest. This area is celebrated for its industrial background, sports enthusiasts, characteristic bungalows, and strong community churches and schools.

Widespread Joy for the First American Pope

Born in Chicago in 1955, Leo attended St. Mary's of the Assumption, a now-closed school on the city's outskirts, and grew up in Dolton, a nearby suburb. He later graduated from Catholic Theological Union in Hyde Park with a Master's in Divinity in 1982, the year he became ordained.

Reverend William Lego, also of the Augustinian Order, remembers studying alongside Leo throughout their education and priesthood. "Adjusting to his new title is still a bit surreal," Lego confessed.

With shared origins, Lego added, "Chicago is always a source of pride."

For many Chicagoans, including those who know Leo personally, his rise is a point of local pride. Nadia Weer, who sat next to Leo in classrooms for eight years because of their alphabetical proximity, recalled, "His dedication to his beliefs earned him the nickname 'Father Robert' even then."

Stone fondly remembered how even as a child, Leo envisioned leading the church. "Midwestern sensibility highlights his composed nature. Expect him to unite people and be recognized as a key pope," Stone predicted.

A Priestly Path from the Start

Leo’s brother, John Prevost, shared memories with ABC News of Leo's unwavering commitment to his vocation. As kids, Leo would often "play priest," using household items for makeshift altars, John shared.

In recounting Leo's deeply religious family, John mentioned their father's involvement with the Archdiocese of Chicago, and how such commitment led Leo to perpetuate similar traditions in service and justice.

Janet Sisler, once holding a notable archdiocesan role, recollected Leo occasionally visiting during his return trips. "The family's profound faith and dedication were unmistakable," she remarked, reflecting on the family's influence.

Chicago's history of labor movements might also have shaped Leo's sense of community. Stemming from a household where both parents worked, "He comprehends the synthesis of commitment to work, family, and faith," said Sisler. "Here is a pope who grasps the significance of community and its positive role in faith-based service."