Judge Rejects DOJ's Plea to Extend Discovery Wait in Abrego Garcia Case

On Wednesday, a federal judge decided against the Trump administration's proposal to further prolong the discovery phase in the wrongful deportation lawsuit concerning Kilmar Abrego Garcia.

This determination was made shortly after the judge had previously postponed proceedings for a week at the administration's request.

U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis criticized the government for its inactivity regarding the erroneous deportation of Abrego Garcia, demanding quicker discovery procedures.

Abrego Garcia, originally from El Salvador and residing in Maryland with his family, was deported to El Salvador despite a 2019 prohibition against such an action, due to fears for his safety. The Trump administration deported him, citing suspected MS-13 gang involvement.

Following her decisive ruling on Wednesday, Judge Xinis established new deadlines for the administration to comply with information requests.

Upcoming Deadlines and Legal Actions

Judge Xinis mandated the government to address all pending discovery queries by May 5, adhering to previous judicial directives regarding privilege claims.

The court specified that four government employees, believed to have pertinent knowledge of the case, must submit to depositions by May 9.

Moreover, the possibility exists for Abrego Garcia's legal representatives to request permission for two further depositions.

Plaintiffs are tasked with submitting renewed motions for relief by May 12, continuing their demand that the administration ensure Abrego Garcia's safe return to the U.S. and provide justification for any non-compliance with court orders.

The administration has until May 14 to present their counterarguments to these renewed motions.

Dispute Over Gang Affiliation

Despite acknowledging that Abrego Garcia's deportation might have been a mistake, the Trump administration points to his alleged gang ties as a bar to his U.S. return—a claim disputed by his family and lawyer.

In 2019, an immigration judge found justification for removal based on purported local police evidence linking him to gang activities, yet provided an order stopping his deportation.

Earlier this month, Judge Xinis specified that the Trump administration must assist in bringing Abrego Garcia back, a ruling that the Supreme Court confirmed, acknowledging the executive branch's role in foreign relations.

Political Reaction

President Trump, in a notable discussion marking his 100th day in office, stated he could facilitate Abrego Garcia's return if warranted, though emphasized the decision isn't his alone.